The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[Kevinsaurus]

I've got these bids on my Grinner I was wondering if they were fair or not

|x||x||x||x||x|

I would say that the first one is closest - The others are nowhere near fair.

Thank you! What should be added to the first and third ones to make them fair?

1st and 3rd are both roughly around fair, slightly overpaying for the grinner. I'd personally prefer the 3rd.

GWJ + Green sorbet for nonjewel?

unfair to the gwj side

[Pippi]

Is this fair..?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... j51wvKlfXg

~ nagema

I think it's awesome! ^^
LOLOLOLOLOLOL X3333

[Saphiria]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... A9cFGUnfTA
Is this fair?

[Kevinsaurus]

Is this fair..?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... j51wvKlfXg

~ nagema

I think it's awesome! ^^
LOLOLOLOLOLOL X3333

What kind of a response is this? If this is some indicator that you're the other side of this trade, you shouldn't be responding at all. Also, saying it's awesome and lol'ing is not helpful advice whatsoever. Don't make posts like this.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23936013&userid=383771&signature=Bb7nKtBFQaSqA9cFGUnfTA
Is this fair?

From a rarity-standpoint, slightly unfair to you. Line tribal and joker bun are a straight swap rarity-wise. Demand-wise, they're overpaying.

[bubiza]

[url==http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23936067&userid=263056&signature=4EUHa5no8063rphAadFk5A]is this fair?[/url]

[Kevinsaurus]

is this fair?

unfair to you

[Aperture Science]

Hyena Bunny + Firework PPS for Orange Grinner?

[Kevinsaurus]

Hyena Bunny + Firework PPS for Orange Grinner?

Unfair to grinner, add ~5 mid-late '09 rares to the bunny side.

[Aperture Science]

Hyena Bunny + Firework PPS for Orange Grinner?

Unfair to grinner, add ~5 mid-late '09 rares to the bunny side.

Thank you! Any other opinions?

[Guepardo]

Is this trade fair..?
Click.