The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

[KathrynKat]

I would like to know the fairness rate of this offer given just as of so far! Click!

To make it a little more easy in case you miss any pets!
- 1 DIY Full Cake Set
- Dark Leopard Dog (High September)
- Christmas Tree Dog (Mid Advent)
- Gearback Tribal (14th tier Main List)
- Spotted Tribal (Top Tier bellow Gap Main List)
- Line Tribal (8th Tier Main List)
- Blue Toxic (near top of bellow gap main list)
- Snowflake B-Wolf (Mid Advent)
- Red Android (Mid/Low Advent)
- Winged Blood Dog (5th Tier September)
- 9 7th Tier Dogs
- 2 Flop-Eared Pink Septembers (Mid September)
- Pink Striped September (Mid/Low September)
- Pink Patchy September (Mid/Low September)
- Light Leopard (Low September)
- BMD Bun (6th Tier Advent)
- Seal Store Dog (6th Tier Advent)
- 70+ Rares
- 4 older store pets (2012-2013 non list)
- 7 Very rare (I believe)
- Many Non Rare
- 404 C$

For SunJewel

Full Set of Tribal dogs, so that is a fairly small bonus to me!

[EverGnar]

What should I add to make this fair?

[heir]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=36810429&userid=628503&signature=SJHbvyeLHlDW7HMstqYC5A
URGENT FAIR OR NOT

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Fair? Thanks I'm advance! ^^

Unfair to you a bit :3

Thanks! Can I get a second opinion?

its unfair to the top actually ^^

[Takk]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=36810429&userid=628503&signature=SJHbvyeLHlDW7HMstqYC5A
URGENT FAIR OR NOT

Unfair to you with the longtail being an '09 rare

[gallifrey falls.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=36810429&userid=628503&signature=SJHbvyeLHlDW7HMstqYC5A
URGENT FAIR OR NOT

{ Technically unfair to you, but the fact they are asking for a simple 08 VR rather than a List pet is wonderful in itself. Shimas can go for more, so I would definitely take that offer ^^

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=36810429&userid=628503&signature=SJHbvyeLHlDW7HMstqYC5A
URGENT FAIR OR NOT

{ Technically unfair to you, but the fact they are asking for a simple 08 VR rather than a List pet is wonderful in itself. Shimas can go for more, so I would definitely take that offer ^^

agreed
Shimas can get advent list pets pretty easily
So though rarity wise it's unfair to you, zee and wise it's a good trade

[DuckGoesRawr]

If I were to offer 135 C$ on Cloudtail, Scourge, Jayfeather, Sandstorm, Crowfeather warrior cats and Malk tiger cat would that be enough to pay?

Thank you very much in advance

EAch true warrior is worth about 20-25 C$. So 20 x 5, that's 100 C$. I think the malk cat is about 20 something C$, making it a bit unfair to you.

Thats untrue, each 2010 rare warrior (true or not) is worth 20-25CS and this is includes the ones from September/November 2009 as they were re releases. Older warriors are worth more than 20C$.
Scourge is only an Uncommon and would only be worth 5-10C$
Crowfeather is worth a mid-late 2009 VR making him worth around 35C$
Cloudtail is worth 20-25C$
Jayfeather is worth a mid-late 2010 rare making him worth around 20-25C$
Sandstorm is worth a mid-late 2009 VR and would only be worth around 35C$
Malk Toyger Cat is worth around 30C$

Making the minimum total 145C$ and the maximum total 170C$, dependant on how you value them, either way its unfair to them ^^

[Dragonborn Comes]

Was this fair?
If not who was it unfair to and by how much?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AUz_svGzJQ

[DuckGoesRawr]

Was this fair?
If not who was it unfair to and by how much?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AUz_svGzJQ

That looks quite unfair to them, since a Sunjewel is worth 5 nons, a non is worth 3 sorbets which would equal 15 sorbets, and im not seeing anything close to 15 sorbets in that trade ^^ The only significant pets/items i saw on your side was a Spotted Tribal, Line tribal, Blue tox and the DIY Cake set, together worth about 3-4 sorbets at a guess, the rest of the trade is worth no where near another 11-12 Sorbets c: