The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[boston]

Is this a fair offer I sent? Thanks in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92052242&userid=641753&signature=6oq6vyn0FiD_2z-3h2ygvg

[beestie]

some folks have edited their bids, so i'd like a revaluation of the values! a quick answer would be great, please.

x / x / x

and there's these two by the same person.

x / x

i'd really appreciate some help with these bids!

my auction ends today, i'd really, really appreciate an answer.

[NonbinaryNobody]

how's this trade i sent?
is the ur fox consistently going for 1.5 nons?

also, would a blue rose be a fair 1:1 swap for a red rose with current demand? thank you for any/all responses <3

Your right the UR Fox is going for 1.5 nons or 1,200/2,000 chicken dollars.

Purple Toxic goes for 0.5 nons or 900 to 1,000 chicken dollars.

Non Tag dogs goes for 10/12 MA.
(1,200/1,600)

Seems fair to me.

Also, Blue rose goes for 2.25 MA. (Worth about 280 to 325 chicken dollars)

Red rose goes for 2 to 3 MA. (450 to 525 Chicken Dollars)

Which is probably not a fair trade)

[dvnc]

hey !! can i get some opinions on these trades??
x
xx

[Mykie]

could i get a couple opinions?
I'm trying to auction off the rat for quantity and this is the best offer i've gotten so far?

[kököchin]

how's this trade i sent?
is the ur fox consistently going for 1.5 nons?

also, would a blue rose be a fair 1:1 swap for a red rose with current demand? thank you for any/all responses <3

Your right the UR Fox is going for 1.5 nons or 1,200/2,000 chicken dollars.

Purple Toxic goes for 0.5 nons or 900 to 1,000 chicken dollars.

Non Tag dogs goes for 10/12 MA.
(1,200/1,600)

Seems fair to me.

Also, Blue rose goes for 2.25 MA. (Worth about 280 to 325 chicken dollars)

Red rose goes for 2 to 3 MA. (450 to 525 Chicken Dollars)

Which is probably not a fair trade)

ahh thank you so much <3 may i get a second opinion on the rose dogs tho?
how much would either side have to add?

[NonbinaryNobody]

hey !! can i get some opinions on these trades??
x
xx

Second trade:

Malk PPS pup is worth 3 to 4 rares. (150/250 in chicken dollars)

Blue Snowflake Scarf Dog goes for 3 to 4 rares. (150C$)

Fair.

[Aemond]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91896878&userid=979673&signature=Z_3kHFezsEKEnpA9wKPa5w
Hi, this is a very tempting trade, I really love the pocky item! Is this fair, and if it isn't what would make it fair?

[ahirked]

some folks have edited their bids, so i'd like a revaluation of the values! a quick answer would be great, please.

x / x / x

and there's these two by the same person.

x / x

i'd really appreciate some help with these bids!

most recent 'pet worth' advice puts them at around an MA each in value (source; also reiterated here; successful trades) - so let's say a set is 3 MAs (21-24 09 rares)

trade 1:
- 8x 09 rares worth (5 09 rares, 6 2010 rares)
- 2012 store = MA
- May lioness = MA (source)
- 2019 stores (x3) = mid-2010 rare ea. (1.5 09 rares)
- tufted blood dog = 6-7 09 rares (source)
- 50c$ == 2009 very rare(?)
== 4 MAs + ~2.5 09 rares

trade 2:
- 7 09 rares
- cream santa hat = 1 MA
- pink striped sept = 1.5-2 MAs
- 2016 store = 09 rare
- 2018 store = early 2010 rare
- 2010 rare
- 100c$ = tier 10 advent apparently (scroll to the bottom, I am unable to link it), but for the sake of clarity 3-4 09 rares
== 3.5-4 MAs + 5-6 09 rares

trade 3:
- red rose = 2-3 MAs
- 2 09 rares + 2010 rare + 2011 rare + 2012 rare
== 2-3 MAs + 2.5 09 rares + 2011 rare + 2012 rare

trade 4 + add
- pink grinner (x2) == 1.5-2 MAs each, so 3-4 MAs
- santa hat cat = 6-7 09 rares
- 6 09 rares + 2012 uc + 2020 r
== 4-5 MAs + 5 09 rares and add

if I've missed something or got something wrong please let me know! I used a mixture of the successful trades thread, pet worth thread and the previous "is this a fair trade" for the evaluations (:
I'd get a second opinion jic!

[Panda-Love-100]

would this trade be fair?
xxx