The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Eagle's Eye]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=65254840&userid=421490&signature=UGLCHJEtqGdoofzqV-ddDA
HI! Is this a fair trade? Thank you so much!

The top is overpaying because of the age gap. Your side is worth a bit more than half of the very rare's value

[XXGemstoneXX]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... h45z7yLF5g

Meiw

[TheUnknown12]

Is this fair? Thank you for the help.

[mooney]

Is this fair? Thank you for the help.

their side = tier 4 advent plus three 09 rares = 7-8 09 rares + a 09 uncommon
your pet is worth 7-8 09 rares so they're overpaying by an 09 uncommon.

[DBD]

Is this fair? Thank you for the help.

their side = tier 4 advent plus three 09 rares = 7-8 09 rares + a 09 uncommon
your pet is worth 7-8 09 rares so they're overpaying by an 09 uncommon.

So yours is a teir 7 advent list pet. They offered a teir four list pet. Teir four list pets don't go for much and in the long run, teir 7s can get you a lot. They're used for filling in gaps in trades. Now. They then add two 2015 list pets, and two rares. That doesn't fill the he gap. Even though the normal rare dogs are from 2009 it doesn't cut it. 2015 list pets aren't worth that much and can't make a jump through the list that high. Honestly it's not worth it demand wise, but it's fine technically.

[mooney]

Is this fair? Thank you for the help.

their side = tier 4 advent plus three 09 rares = 7-8 09 rares + a 09 uncommon
your pet is worth 7-8 09 rares so they're overpaying by an 09 uncommon.

So yours is a teir 7 advent list pet. They offered a teir four list pet. Teir four list pets don't go for much and in the long run, teir 7s can get you a lot. They're used for filling in gaps in trades. Now. They then add two 2015 list pets, and two rares. That doesn't fill the he gap. Even though the normal rare dogs are from 2009 it doesn't cut it. 2015 list pets aren't worth that much and can't make a jump through the list that high. Honestly it's not worth it demand wise, but it's fine technically.

a tier 4 advent pet is worth 4-5 09 rares + an 09 uncommon (this information can be found right here). adding three 09 rares to that, the lion side is worth 7-8 09 rares + a 09 uncommon, like I said above. that's one 09 uncommon too much, since a tier 7 advent is worth only 7-8 09 rares.

(one 2015 store pet is worth an early 2010 rare so together the two store pets are worth an early 09 rare)

edit: I miscalculated. a tier 4 advent is worth 5-6 09 rares, so the lion side is worth 8-9 09 rares. they're overpaying by an 09 rare c:

[Eagle's Eye]

Is this fair? Thank you for the help.

their side = tier 4 advent plus three 09 rares = 7-8 09 rares + a 09 uncommon
your pet is worth 7-8 09 rares so they're overpaying by an 09 uncommon.

So yours is a teir 7 advent list pet. They offered a teir four list pet. Teir four list pets don't go for much and in the long run, teir 7s can get you a lot. They're used for filling in gaps in trades. Now. They then add two 2015 list pets, and two rares. That doesn't fill the he gap. Even though the normal rare dogs are from 2009 it doesn't cut it. 2015 list pets aren't worth that much and can't make a jump through the list that high. Honestly it's not worth it demand wise, but it's fine technically.

Please only give educated advice.
Tier 4 pets could be used to fill gaps in trades but tier 7 pets also do that too.
The gap between a tier 4 and a tier 7 is 2 2009 rares. The top is offering the worth of 3 '09 rares along with their advent tier 4. They're overpaying by a '09 rare.

[HappyPineapple]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DkdVXmaYqQ

Could I please have some help as to wether to accept this or not. I haven't been active for a while and sort of forgot my rarities. Please and thank you <3

[Halsie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... riIl5zEJuA

They sent. Fair and would you accept?

[Eagle's Eye]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=65259102&userid=54445&signature=1d341Smx0ZB1DkdVXmaYqQ

Could I please have some help as to wether to accept this or not. I haven't been active for a while and sort of forgot my rarities. Please and thank you <3

Your item is worth a mid '09 rare/very rare by rarity. The dog they're offering had an extended release until 2010 so it's unfair to you

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=65258704&userid=656194&signature=FUgTckzihl-0riIl5zEJuA

They sent. Fair and would you accept?

C$ guide. A 2016 store pet is worth 25-30C$ so this is fair. I wouldn't accept because I personally prefer store pets over C$