The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[beemo]

I got a bunch of trades for my Malk Elemental Cats and seriously need help. I am a bit overwhelmed with that decision rn and feel like cancel all of them bc I feel like I can only make a dumb decision^^

Cake Dog for 2 Elemental Cats
Bunch of '09er and '10er for 1 Malk Cat
TRUEDATE Target Dog for 3 Cats (Supplied with a lot of proof that TD Target Dog is 3 MA)
Bulk Items and Pets, most valuable Item is 1 Confetti if I see right, pets it's 2 '09 vr and 3 '10 rare for 1 Cat

personally, i wouldn't accept any of them. td target dog may go for 3 ma, but td malk elementals can go for 2 ma each. it's not fair for them to add value to their td pet but not add value to yours.

[mymelody<3]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105317848&userid=1064257&signature=4g3xIGJ9c4-tS-A-4IC3KA - okay this on would be fair right? I did the math and I think it is
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105320721&userid=1064257&signature=9hymADlw9r68q_JIdw6bnw - havent done the math so I'm not sure if this would be fair.
Would one be better than the other? Tysm to any help!♡

[keayi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105317848&userid=1064257&signature=4g3xIGJ9c4-tS-A-4IC3KA - okay this on would be fair right? I did the math and I think it is
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105320721&userid=1064257&signature=9hymADlw9r68q_JIdw6bnw - havent done the math so I'm not sure if this would be fair.
Would one be better than the other? Tysm to any help!♡

1)
'10 UC = .25 '09 R
'10 R = .5 '09 R
3 '12 R = 1.5 '11 R = .75 =10 R = .375 '09 R
1.125 '09 R so far.
2 '16 R
2 '23 R
Mirror Necklace = ?

For:
'19 Store = 1 '09 R

Technically fair.

2)
'11 R = .5 '10 R = .25 '09 R
2 '12 R = 1 '11 R = .25 '09 R
3 '14 R = 1.5 '13 R = .75 '12 R = .375 '11 R = .15 '10 R = .075 '09 R
0.575 '09 R so far
2 '16 R
'17 R

For:
'19 Store = 1 '09 R

Unfair to you

[DisneyLuv]

Would you accept this trade?

Click

[~Heizou~]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105320859&userid=957390&signature=iI-VB4bqxytJypZU_oqOiw

Was this fair?^^

[winx]

New thread here: Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4873607

Congrats on 900+ pages everyone!