The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Deerdancer]

Is this fair? Involves an item for two items:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99620292&userid=203847&signature=9NtXX-_0AHE0ECIO5L_orw
and this involves two pets for a pet and some items:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99659032&userid=203847&signature=EOcjA2UFEiKa952jTepLog

[TibblesNbits]

This ornament is worth 1 MA. Does this add up to 1 MA?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99751929&userid=901965&signature=09JgzWnWOTChLla82Siuww

It adds up to six 2009 rares and one 2010 rare, each store pet there is worth a 2010 rare. An Ma is six-nine 2009 rares so it does equal an Ma but the call is yours.

[TibblesNbits]

thoughts on this guy?

ty!

The roadkill pps goes for ~1-2 Ma. The tuffed blood dog goes for one Ma and the warrior cat also goes for one Ma.

[smiledawg]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99748577&userid=865121&signature=sQ4ERRsqAiCmuQr2gh5a4g

need help with this!!!

still need help

[pirelliskrt]

pls help lmao- pm me-
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99752067&userid=827243&signature=0b1rMTp-WnMkkaApjnNb4Q

[TibblesNbits]

Trade

They literally cited trades in the message they sent i just want confirmation because I am really illiterate in CS rarity >.<

You might want a second opinion but if I'm right the car is 1 ma and the zodiac is 2-3 '09 rares (I'm sure about zodiac worth;; not entirely sure about the sitting Cats!)

Which in your case would put you over since the alpaca is already 1 ma and the other 2013 store pet goes for 0.5-1 MA,, (in that case already making this trade over)

Let alone if you consider that the PPS fennec fox can often grab higher than it's worth due to demand !

Second opinion here, I agree with everything stated above. You're overpaying by quite a bit. I recommend editing down.

[TibblesNbits]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99748577&userid=865121&signature=sQ4ERRsqAiCmuQr2gh5a4g

need help with this!!!

still need help

Each of your 2021 store cats is worth a 2010 rare. Even with the bulk it does not make up three 2010 rares.

[TibblesNbits]

pls help lmao- pm me-
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99752067&userid=827243&signature=0b1rMTp-WnMkkaApjnNb4Q

A Ur rat goes for ~.5 Non which is 1000 C$. Even with it not being a true date I don't believe 500 C$ is fair.

[TibblesNbits]

May I get help please? I got this trade and I know that some of these are in fact higher than what they're offering

They're going by "40 C$ per rat | 45 C$ per butterfly wolf | 50 C$ per dog"

Can you guys let me know how much more I should be asking or maybe the values of the higher end pets??

Thanks so much !

It depends on the pet, could you link the trade so we can value the pets?

[Rbpuppy]

Thoughts on this one? I do love the yellow toxic c:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99717022&userid=42960&signature=x0hxRiyRCJp9E7h6ZQNhiQ

With the yellow toxic being true date it goes for about .75- 1 non , the bunny suit is another 2 MA .
Your RR Black Advent is 1 non.
It’s a decent offer imo and I personally would consider because of the true date of the toxic, but it’s up to you which you like more .

Trade

Not great with math. The item is from Christmas 2009 and is a Malk item if that matters. I’ve been told event items typically go for an uncommon from their release year but I want to see if this one is worth more due to age.

While most items are valued at an uncommon of their release year the same doesn’t apply to older items, certain event items, retired store items ect. Always good to double check here if you are unsure of the items worth like you did .

The horse figurines go for a 09 rare min so this trade offer would be unfair to you .

Thank you!