The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[miskit]

can I get some info on the values here? I really like the pets theyre offering but I'm not sure what the value of the UR tree is

[keayi]

can I get some info on the values here? I really like the pets theyre offering but I'm not sure what the value of the UR tree is

4 '09 VR warrior = at least 1 MA/ea = 4 MA
'09 R
Yellow Punk = 0.5 Nons
4 '19 Store sitting cats = '09 R/ea = 4 '09 R
4 '19 Store lions = '09 R/ea = 4 '09 R
-----
Total rares = 9 '09 R = ~1 MA
Total MA = 4 (+ ~1) = ~5 MA = ~0.5 Nons
Total Nons = ~1.0 Nons


For:
UR Orange Tree = 1.5-2 Nons currently

This is under by half a non at least, you could probably find more for the UR orange tree.

Feel free to get another opinion though, b/c I don't know how well the tree trades personally. A lot of the non-animal URs eventually become worth 1 Non but maybe the tree isn't there yet.

[unickorn]

Could use help:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105318493&userid=887920&signature=Z0kUEHGbXUVFf40BhECz6g

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105318488&userid=887920&signature=f2deQ8VhjMSEO6qA-tyBFg

[keayi]

Could use help:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105318493&userid=887920&signature=Z0kUEHGbXUVFf40BhECz6g

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105318488&userid=887920&signature=f2deQ8VhjMSEO6qA-tyBFg

1)
single colored RBM = reg. '09 VR = 2 '09 R

For:
Spider bwolf = low October = 0.5 MA

Unfair to you, the bwolf has more value.

2)
Lion seal and 7 C$

For:
1 Marshmallow (queue spongebob reference) = 2014 Halloween = '14 UC ?

I believe 7 C$ is fair for a '14 uncommon so the unknown rarity is a lil bonus. But c$ are tentative to everyone and everyone sets their own prices so... upto youuu

[kijauni]

I got a bunch of trades for my Malk Elemental Cats and seriously need help. I am a bit overwhelmed with that decision rn and feel like cancel all of them bc I feel like I can only make a dumb decision^^

Cake Dog for 2 Elemental Cats
Bunch of '09er and '10er for 1 Malk Cat
TRUEDATE Target Dog for 3 Cats (Supplied with a lot of proof that TD Target Dog is 3 MA)
Bulk Items and Pets, most valuable Item is 1 Confetti if I see right, pets it's 2 '09 vr and 3 '10 rare for 1 Cat

[alicewins]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105318536&userid=767773&signature=zBcFVbQDD5ESYA0RWKX6cQ

I’m not sure I recognize any of the pets they’re offering - is this fair or close to fair?

[keayi]

I got a bunch of trades for my Malk Elemental Cats and seriously need help. I am a bit overwhelmed with that decision rn and feel like cancel all of them bc I feel like I can only make a dumb decision^^

Cake Dog for 2 Elemental Cats
Bunch of '09er and '10er for 1 Malk Cat
TRUEDATE Target Dog for 3 Cats (Supplied with a lot of proof that TD Target Dog is 3 MA)
Bulk Items and Pets, most valuable Item is 1 Confetti if I see right, pets it's 2 '09 vr and 3 '10 rare for 1 Cat

Elemental Malk Cats = 1-2 MA/ea (I'm finding trades for them to be across the board...)

1) light bro cake dog = 2 MA (so trade is valuing 1 ma/per cat)
2) 8.5 '09 Rs worth = ~1 MA (1 ma/per cat)
3) TD target dog = 2-3 MA (0.6-1 ma/per cat)
4) 5.5 '09 R = 0.75 MA (plus 2 '23 Stores = 2 '11 R plus assorted C/UC in both pets and items. Nice bulk won't add up to 1 MA i'm afraid...) (less than 1 MA/per cat)

If you're looking for the best trade, I'd go with the target dog. There's also nothing wrong with saving your malks for something you really want, they have the demand to be traded for more.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105318536&userid=767773&signature=zBcFVbQDD5ESYA0RWKX6cQ

I’m not sure I recognize any of the pets they’re offering - is this fair or close to fair?

Hoshike ember bday dog = reg. '09 VR
Blizzard dog = reg. '09 VR
Coraline GUPPS = reg. '09 VR
Moonflight bobtail = reg. '09 VR
Total = 8 '09 Rs worth

For:
Yellow toxic = at least 0.5 Nons = 50-75 '09 R

Not worth it

[alicewins]

Thank you keayi!

[Mistwing]

Is this trade fair?

[bubblegumjello]

x