The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ηαтαlιє]

I need some help... Is it fair to trade

this Cake dog for the Green Toxic Bun?
Thanks in advance <3

[Lopez]

Big trade! Is this anywhere near fair? I'm not good with worth of high-value/old list pets so some insight on this would be appreciated

[kxynine]

Is this fair? Trade

If you look up the Ex-list they are in the same tier and worth the same in C$. So I would think this must be ok.
Edit: I looked up an older List too and there the UR Cinnabun is one tier under the Coontail, so in this case it would be a little but unfair to them.

Please don't give false advice
Both the coon tail and the Cinnabun go for 1.5-2 nons with consistency (coon x & x) (cinnabun x)
Also I suggest not using the old list, and instead refer to newer ones as the old one is very outdated

[ηαтαlιє]

Is this fair? Trade

If you look up the Ex-list they are in the same tier and worth the same in C$. So I would think this must be ok.
Edit: I looked up an older List too and there the UR Cinnabun is one tier under the Coontail, so in this case it would be a little but unfair to them.

Please don't give false advice
Both the coon tail and the Cinnabun go for 1.5-2 nons with consistency (coon x & x) (cinnabun x)
Also I suggest not using the old list, and instead refer to newer ones as the old one is very outdated

Well the list I looked at said 1.5-2 nons for both (I wrote "they are in the same tier") so I don't think my "must be ok" was a false advice...



I'm looking for help with this trade...
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97518469&userid=358634&signature=Mg-2dZHHPfuGi1B6yfF41w
Thanks in advance <3

[rainfall.]

hi all! could i get some advice on this trade? thank you!!

[airen]

is this fair?

I’m trying to complete my butterfly wolf collection so this is tempting, I just wanted to check as I’m not sure of the lion’s value either!

thank you ^^

[Sharkyy]

Would this be fair? I’m not good with worths, but especially these dec 18s

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97516672&userid=891706&signature=c7ULORACg9KxP8Eu0UBP-g

[CloudFyre]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=97518776&userid=447151&signature=x6HsZCn3Bw0pGUbeqExLrg

[gяεч]

would these trades be fair? (both for the same pet)
(1) & (2), thanks in advance

[godot]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=97518776&userid=447151&signature=x6HsZCn3Bw0pGUbeqExLrg

Very unfair to the basilisk (your store pet), which last I remember gets at least 2 Mid Advents (that's roughly 14-16 2009 rares) if not more nowadays
I may not be super sure on the value so someone else feel free to chime in but I can definitely tell this is underpay bigtime