The "is this a fair trade?" thread [notice 2nd post]

[Ashki]

Auction Bid Would you consider this an autowin for the new August store pets? [because of the 08 rare albeit a bwolf]
First auction so I'm antsy and don't really care to wait too long for more bids.
It's all Wishlist.
Someone told me that the Llamas were worth a mid to late '10 rare each.
So It would be nice to hear about it from another person's perspective.
Any help is appreciated!

Yeah, the new store pets are worth a mid '10 each. So I'd definitely go for that bid. ^^

[muted.wolf]

Auction Bid Would you consider this an autowin for the new August store pets? [because of the 08 rare albeit a bwolf]
First auction so I'm antsy and don't really care to wait too long for more bids.
It's all Wishlist.
Someone told me that the Llamas were worth a mid to late '10 rare each.
So It would be nice to hear about it from another person's perspective.
Any help is appreciated!

Yeah, the new store pets are worth a mid '10 each. So I'd definitely go for that bid. ^^

Thanks for the input! Any other thoughts?

[lucky333123]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=28880104&userid=45104&signature=_d3zAARQZBfb8oVQCDXEPw

Is this fair? Or what could be changed to make it fair?

Unfair to the bottom

[Ashki]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=28880104&userid=45104&signature=_d3zAARQZBfb8oVQCDXEPw

Is this fair? Or what could be changed to make it fair?

Quite unfair to you. ^^ Four of the 09 rares should be good.

[resque]

Auction Bid Would you consider this an autowin for the new August store pets? [because of the 08 rare albeit a bwolf]
First auction so I'm antsy and don't really care to wait too long for more bids.
It's all Wishlist.
Someone told me that the Llamas were worth a mid to late '10 rare each.
So It would be nice to hear about it from another person's perspective.
Any help is appreciated!

Yeah, the new store pets are worth a mid '10 each. So I'd definitely go for that bid. ^^

Thanks for the input! Any other thoughts?

I agree. C:

[extraterrestrial]

is this fair?
I think so but im not suuure
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KBGdBbn1gA

[Ashki]

is this fair?
I think so but im not suuure
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KBGdBbn1gA

Yup, that's a fair swap. ^^

[Lindsey.]

yes it is^^

[Skye Selkie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=28882287&userid=428587&signature=5eysVW_V7ygM8VjEGaFzaw
It's a suggestion I sent but I was wondering is it fair? If not
what would be fair/could make it fair?

[discombobulated]

Bid one: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YdSq3JUDRQ
Bid two: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tMBvHrDdqw
Got these two bids in my auction and I'm leaning towards the first one but before I do anything I would like to ask which one is better.
Thank you in advance c: