The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Mistwing]

quote="Lex."]

Is this trade fair?

'18 UC
19 UC = 2 '20 UC = 4 '20 C
2 '22 UC (c incl) = 1 '21 UC = .5 '20 UC = 1 '20 C

For:
'18 C
2 '20 C (vc incl)

Their side is worth more

Thanks!

-----------------------

Can I get a second opinion, please?

Seconding keayi, it's overpay on their side[/quote]

Thanks!

[Kiamsc]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105317781&userid=138141&signature=O7pGTActNH8PfuLKAvaxbw
I am so bad at balancing trades okay but it's not super important if ya'll are busy. The like 2 or 3 to 1 rule feels like way too much for years for me but I still have trouble deciding values personally.

[mymelody<3]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105317848&userid=1064257&signature=4g3xIGJ9c4-tS-A-4IC3KA
I feel like they are under paying right? Tysm to any help!♡

[beemo]

Could i get some help on this trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105312335&userid=957390&signature=aCAkSqaucJK-ilko53Nymg

I Did all of the math so i think its fair- but i just want to make sure <3

Okay, so its
4MA for all of the Zodiacs
2MA for the VR Warriors
3.5MA for the Rare Warriors
4MA for the goatish 1012 stores
And we can round the random rares to like 1.5MA?

that actually comes out to 15 MA

And the UR Foal = 12MA
Target Dog = 2MA
Heavy Orange Stripe dog = 1MA

Could I get a second opinion on this?^^

I would personally value the Foal at the lower end of the 10-12 MA value due to its demand so I would personally add an extra 2 MA to your side to make it fair.
However, do be aware that you are offering a fairly low demand pet for a whole bunch of very high demand pets!

i'm going to agree with this. even if it's "fair", asking for quantity AND quality while the majority of your offer is a low demand pet, is a bit much. trading down lower demand pets while also asking for higher demand pets usually means you aren't going to get the full value.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105315681&userid=767773&signature=hjdw9u45nWM96vDwI4Dsyg

Do these lions have any special value or is it just 3 month rule? Thank you!

as far as i'm aware, the three month rule. so it just depends on which you prefer!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105314071&userid=1076598&signature=Ft15NcB4dmRblW96UUSFMw Pretty sure my elemental malk is worth 1MA so would it be fair for me to ask them to add another ferret ?

yes, definitely ask for another. your cat being a td also increases it's value a bit more. i would personally say it's 1.5 - 2 ma. if trading for store pets though, which also have very good demand, asking for 1.5 ma seems fair!

[Ancient Frost]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105317883&userid=834666&signature=3NQCuPeGrjd_IaszNuDFeQ

I don't know how items translate to pets. Could someone help me out?

[beemo]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105317883&userid=834666&signature=3NQCuPeGrjd_IaszNuDFeQ

I don't know how items translate to pets. Could someone help me out?

aside from older items, items are generally valued at a common/uncommon from their year. those items are from halloween 2017, so i would say they're overpaying a bit!

[PastelDog]

So, I'm not the best with item trades or large trades. I'm hoping someone can help me.

Pet trade is here - mostly uncommons with a few rares

Items trade is here

Still need advice please and thank you

[~Heizou~]

Could I get another opinion on this trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105317950&userid=957390&signature=GajI-FhN4lZVDHdh0x4P_Q

Is 12ma fair to put the UR Foal around?

[dionaea]

could i get some advice please?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105317956&userid=204354&signature=BlPyTBacCWAxdRJSAuMe8A

[Cloverstream]

Ik item trades are a long shot but well I might as well try. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105317938&userid=223834&signature=OrfhqnYiwzS6Vaxkfa1WfA