The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Gordon]

Could I get some opinions on this offer for my UR Pumpkin? I think the items add up to about 3 nons worth right? My goal is to complete my UR pet collection and I know the market for items is pretty small compared to the market for pets, so how easily can these items be traded for their pet values? Or how much would I realistically be able to get for these items? Would you personally accept it?

[Mally2678]

Small Uncommon trade
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97515679&userid=938674&signature=qnf5oIewY-sPadYqgHw1jQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97499749&userid=938674&signature=-H4ZFpg_3oZ_v-IBkaJT5Q
I know this is fair Rarity wise but is it worth taking

Any help with these is appreciated!

[kxynine]

Small Uncommon trade
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97515679&userid=938674&signature=qnf5oIewY-sPadYqgHw1jQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97499749&userid=938674&signature=-H4ZFpg_3oZ_v-IBkaJT5Q
I know this is fair Rarity wise but is it worth taking

Any help with these is appreciated!

The first is (rarity wise) unfair to the squid, as the '17 uncommon doesn't add up to the gap. Tho I'm pretty sure dogs have better demand than the squid so it's personal preference.

Last one is fair by rarity, but once again it's personal preference. I'd personally stick with the store pet.

[Pumpkin~Spice]

Is this fair? The Cream Santa advert for a tier 7 advert list? If not, what needs to be added to my side? Any help is appreciated.
Click

[kxynine]

Is this fair? The Cream Santa advert for a tier 7 advert list? If not, what needs to be added to my side? Any help is appreciated.
Click

According to this guide it's a fair swap as they're in the same tier, so it's just personal preference for what you prefer.
Unsure if either of them have any specific demand, tho the husky might get a bit more than the cream santa

[lucky400l]

Is this trade fair to me?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97517737&userid=816147&signature=U0McH0vyYEpgbS0AmTpi1Q

[Pumpkin~Spice]

Is this fair? The Cream Santa advert for a tier 7 advert list? If not, what needs to be added to my side? Any help is appreciated.
Click

According to this guide it's a fair swap as they're in the same tier, so it's just personal preference for what you prefer.
Unsure if either of them have any specific demand

Thank you! I was told the cream santa hat is tier 5? Is that true? Or is that the old list?

[nicole]

Is this fair? The Cream Santa advert for a tier 7 advert list? If not, what needs to be added to my side? Any help is appreciated.
Click

According to this guide it's a fair swap as they're in the same tier, so it's just personal preference for what you prefer.
Unsure if either of them have any specific demand

Thank you! I was told the cream santa hat is tier 5? Is that true? Or is that the old list?

That's the old list

[Inactive.]

Been asking for a while but could I get any help? I normally pretty good with small list trades but not so certain with this:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97514163&userid=402566&signature=qXlLA1T24ah8qKquOQnnAQ

[AuroraButterflyx]

Fair X