The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[☼find your wings☼]

how many candies should I give my partner for these pets?

[Nari UwU]

How close to fair is this?

Trying to math bulk trades melts my brain x.x tyvm for any help <3

[LavenderHaze]

How close to fair is this?

Trying to math bulk trades melts my brain x.x tyvm for any help <3

You dont necessarily have to do all the math to see if this trade is fair. Your llama is worth an MA/8-9 09 rares. Even though their side is bulky, its all 2016+ and definitely does not add up to 8-9 09 rares

[EmberzTale]

Would this be fair? Mainly looking at the storgi for the carousel horse.

Thanks for any help!

[faerah]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96503910&userid=807042&signature=reme9zK_XoK2tWRfh0dUAw fair?

[cassiemck123]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96503981&userid=958513&signature=PPD4cJ__QC7dC7OTY3irrA

I have no flipping clue if this is fair or not, any help would be greatly appreciated

[Neoncherry64]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96503981&userid=958513&signature=PPD4cJ__QC7dC7OTY3irrA

I have no flipping clue if this is fair or not, any help would be greatly appreciated

I am almost certain this is unfair to them. All your items are newer and worth anywhere from an OMGSC-uncommon each (it depends on if they were in a big free set or bought with tokens) and that store lion is worth way more than all those items alone.

[emmiedee]

I don't know what things are worth on this site anymore. Is this fair? Thanks!

[Klauss]

I dont know if this is fair since i dont know a thing about list pets

[Neoncherry64]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96497384&userid=538817&signature=4LbIeqmVK3JKX4812HzvHw

any opinions on this?

Personally, I'd accept that trade - all of them are old uncommons, and all true dates, making them worth quite a bit, and they want a re-release in turn, rather than a true date. I'd do it!

Edit: this pet is not a list pet, and worth at least one or more ‘09
Rares (depending on who you ask) but I still wouldn’t recommend trading any VR down for uncommons, as most people want to trade down, and not up. You will have an extremely hard time trading those uncommons up for a pet worth the same as the bunny.

Also, uncommons are never rereleased, so every uncommon is “true date” so to speak. You should never judge trade fairness solely on weather a pet is rereleased or not!