The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[floydo]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93172700&userid=338647&signature=lvY4ISVdoBbNBNKv86b8yw
What would this wolf be worth?

[Eagle's Eye]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93172700&userid=338647&signature=lvY4ISVdoBbNBNKv86b8yw
What would this wolf be worth?

3 month rule
for pet values, please use this thread

[snowdrake]

Any thoughts?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93067138&userid=960078&signature=9p2uKQopfC09VCeFSlvOxw

You get the better deal but the one they're asking for is very cool so I would weigh it on how you feel about it; do you like the lil skeleton more than the old, uncommon & rare dogs?

no matter how you look at it, this trade is ridiculously unfair to the quantity side. there is no way the skeleton pps dragon is worth that much. you can definitely trade fairly for it!

[bug]

is this fair?

[little sunshine]

is this fair?

unfair to them due to dates

[bug]

is this fair?

unfair to them due to dates

what would be fair to add on then?

[TheBrokenRobot]

Any thoughts?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93067138&userid=960078&signature=9p2uKQopfC09VCeFSlvOxw

You get the better deal but the one they're asking for is very cool so I would weigh it on how you feel about it; do you like the lil skeleton more than the old, uncommon & rare dogs?

no matter how you look at it, this trade is ridiculously unfair to the quantity side. there is no way the skeleton pps dragon is worth that much. you can definitely trade fairly for it!

All resolved now. Thank you everyone <3

[Kabuski]

Opinions?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93185664&userid=795870&signature=3pP_NvghyJHZwM433esPSw

[Cøpacetic]

I’m doing an auction and got this offer:
What is the pet on their side?? What’s it worth? trades/viewtrade.php?id=93175729&userid=881527&signature=_-MDsBl5_fPwhFjbjYxI6w

So I now know it’s a tier 1 advent list pet. Am I right that it wouldn't be fair for my pet? I've read that 2013 store pets typically trade for around an MA

[little sunshine]

I’m doing an auction and got this offer:
What is the pet on their side?? What’s it worth? trades/viewtrade.php?id=93175729&userid=881527&signature=_-MDsBl5_fPwhFjbjYxI6w

So I now know it’s a tier 1 advent list pet. Am I right that it wouldn't be fair for my pet? I've read that 2013 store pets typically trade for around an MA

typically those store pets do go for a low-mid advent
so it's arguably unfair to you due to the potential value