The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Cøpacetic]

I’m doing an auction and got this offer:
What is the pet on their side?? What’s it worth? trades/viewtrade.php?id=93175729&userid=881527&signature=_-MDsBl5_fPwhFjbjYxI6w

So I now know it’s a tier 1 advent list pet. Am I right that it wouldn't be fair for my pet? I've read that 2013 store pets typically trade for around an MA

[Denidene]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93111750&userid=661506&signature=tRFFr3uKWQkdfAthz3dP5g

Also this
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93177499&userid=661506&signature=LOJTZUdGz4T6AdExMsq6xg

Alright, so for the first bid:
Each of the 2021 pets are probably worth around 0.25 each since they are not token pets. Although some might pay 1C$ per pet since they are unknown rarities right now. So that totals to around 1.25-5C$

As for the items:
- The mouse plushie is from 2013 Valentine and worth a 2013 uncommon/common (2-3C$)
- Bear plush, dog plushie are from 2014 Christmas and worth a 2014 uncommon/common (1.5-2 C$)
- Snow globe and snow globe items are from Christmas 2016 and worth a 2016 uncommon/common (1 C$)
- Dragon costume is from Halloween 2017 and worth a 2017 uncommon
- Nessie Plush is from Halloween 2018 and worth a 2018 uncommon/common
- The two dog plushies are from Hanukka and Christmas 2018 and worth a late 2018 uncommon/common
- Horse Plushie is from Chinese New Year 2019 and worth about a 2019 very common
- CS plushie 12 is from CS birthday 2020 and worth about a 2020 very common
- The zombie plushies are from Halloween 2020 and worth a late 2020 common
- Cupid Plushie and Colorful Balayage Wig are from Valentine 2021 and worth about a 2021 very common
- Monarch butterfly is from Easter Event 2021 are worth about a 2021 very common/uncommon since we are still in the Easter Event.
And everything under 2017 would be considered less than 1 C$ (see this thread)
The items would then total up to be around 9-10 C$, maybe even a bit less.
The total would be around 10.25-15C$
Other is slightly overpaying.

The second one is trickier, I would say it is unfair to you.
The wings are a set (friendship set) that came together with the store pets (Friendship dragons).
They can be valued as having the same rarity as the store pets (late 2009 rare), however the set had 26 items. So it is a bit tricky to divide them up.
(According to this post though, each item is roughly worth a 2012 uncommon)

[LoveIsLove]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93141946&userid=317159&signature=fgzMR4X-RCk5v7zUV-3_4w
I don’t trade with c$ much, so I have no idea if this is fair or not. Any help would be appreciated!

I’m on the other side, any opinions would be appreciated!

So a 2017 Store Pet would be worth around 40-45C$ or a mid 2009 rare, may differ depending on demand (but sadly enough I don't know anything about that, sorry 😭)

I would say that it is slighly unfair to the side with C$ because a rare 2010 is worth around 25-30 C$, and each 2019 rare is worth around 3-5C$ but please do ask a second opinion because I have no clue of demand of store pets.

Thank you so much for the response I really appreciate it (even if it’s unfair to me I am willing to overpay so that’s fine)
Would it be possible to get a second opinion perhaps?

[Sali]

Please can I get some help? c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92916123&userid=273533&signature=MHvNkVC5GBKtuc9TQ0ti4Q

and would this be fair?
Eat me & Drink me ser for skeleton Bunny

also this please c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93135004&userid=273533&signature=7qNLLOv1RJxD1qgyToEPNQ

[Stranger Things]

how fair is THIS trade? is it worth it? Would it be easy to trade up with the x pps?

[mimitina]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93150257&userid=180216&signature=YAeyePwmd8Cqx_XEv3ci5g

Fair? If no who overpays? Thanks in advance!

[123tigerlilly]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93183150&userid=630106&signature=Ty8OvM4oRJgEdYQ5JVnE5g

Is this fair?? I have literally no idea

[sxtxrn]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93183150&userid=630106&signature=Ty8OvM4oRJgEdYQ5JVnE5g

Is this fair?? I have literally no idea

over on their end, it adds up to two '12 rares and one '13 rare if going by two uncommons = a rare

[Syn_cat]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93183544&userid=737315&signature=IfPIzaBDAaPOlEOJKogx-A

[Jacintylou]

Anyone tell me how this looks? I received the trade but have no idea
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93183225&userid=207020&signature=SBh-WFaUoSpSt6tp9gZihQ