The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Fat Unicorn]

Two mid 2011 Gryphon store pets = Two mid 2009 rare dogs. Two mid 09 dogs for a 08 dog? nah uh in my opinion, there's no need to get snippy about it. ^^

[spaceguinea]

Unfair to king of spades.

Well, '12 store pets are worth an '09 rare, so 2 '11 for an '08 seems fair to me Sorry if I'm wrong. >.>[/quote]
Actually '12 store pets are worth a 2010 rare...[/quote]
Oh... I've had a million people tell me otherwise >.> Sorry.

[Falkenfire]

Two mid 2011 Gryphon store pets = Two mid 2009 rare dogs. Two mid 09 dogs for a 08 dog? nah uh in my opinion, there's no need to get snippy about it. ^^

Would three be more fair?

[bvrd]

I know this is cancelled but they said it was extremely unfair to them.

[Harpy•]

I know this is cancelled but they said it was extremely unfair to them.

This early on, there is absolutely NO way to tell if it was fair or not.

[-frankiero]

Really?

[Kyar]

I know this is cancelled but they said it was extremely unfair to them.

This early on, there is absolutely NO way to tell if it was fair or not.

You were overpaying even if it does end up rare.

[Fat Unicorn]

I know this is cancelled but they said it was extremely unfair to them.

This early on, there is absolutely NO way to tell if it was fair or not.

It's unfair to Blackbird. If you're offering a pet 3 months older + than the newborn, that's pretty much overpay until the rarity comes out. Even if the newborn was rare, it'd be underpay for the cat.

[Harpy•]

I know this is cancelled but they said it was extremely unfair to them.

This early on, there is absolutely NO way to tell if it was fair or not.

It's unfair to Blackbird. If you're offering a pet 3 months older + than the newborn, that's pretty much overpay until the rarity comes out. Even if the newborn was rare, it'd be underpay for the cat.

Ah, okay. I didn't know that. :) Sorry, never mind what I said :P

[bvrd]

I know this is cancelled but they said it was extremely unfair to them.

This early on, there is absolutely NO way to tell if it was fair or not.

It's unfair to Blackbird. If you're offering a pet 3 months older + than the newborn, that's pretty much overpay until the rarity comes out. Even if the newborn was rare, it'd be underpay for the cat.

Alright, thank you Kyar and Fattu.