The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[saküra]

was this fair .-.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96444030&userid=358339&signature=GOB_FRn0DrZ6cCCD6yjetA

I Know the monster eyes are from 2010

the red monster eyes are worth .25n and their side is worth 2 ma so they were under by 1-2 MA

[Gelée Nova]

Hello!
Could I get some help with valuing their side in this trade? *Large bulk warning*
I personally value my Skelebun around 15-16 nons, would this be close?

Thanks in advance for any advice!

[ElliotEel]

Heelo! Neither of us are sure on values, but I can very clearly tell that's heavy overpay thanks to the C$ — could we get some help evening this out?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=96467194&userid=954605&signature=x4Ux_syQZNK6hlwd4XvtjA

[Geckos_N_Tea]

Heelo! Neither of us are sure on values, but I can very clearly tell that's heavy overpay thanks to the C$ — could we get some help evening this out?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=96467194&userid=954605&signature=x4Ux_syQZNK6hlwd4XvtjA

remove c$ and then add a 2019 rare that should make it about fair to both sides

[Ruruskadoo]

Fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96469847&userid=119355&signature=rOwpPRTuhZNxFCrLvHx3jw

[LavenderHaze]

Fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96469847&userid=119355&signature=rOwpPRTuhZNxFCrLvHx3jw

Unfair to them. Current store pets are worth an 11 rare, your side is only a 16 rare and a 2019 item thats probably only worth a 2019 common-uncommon

[saküra]

Hello!
Could I get some help with valuing their side in this trade? *Large bulk warning*
I personally value my Skelebun around 15-16 nons, would this be close?

Thanks in advance for any advice!

I counted all of the non list pets and they add up to over 120 ‘09 rares so all of that is 1 n and from what I know both the RR and TD skeleton PPS get .25 n so there’s 9 of them in total making that 2.25 n, the hollyfox cats may fetch 1.5 MA due to them being TD so you already have around 3.5n. The warrior cats are 1 MA each so that’s around .5 n for just those. The red malk dragon is worth .25 n and the 2011+ 2012 store pets equal around 2.5-3 MA so with the warrior cats, red malk, and the older store pets that’s another 1 non. PPS malk dragons add up to 3 n so now you have 7 n + the brown sleipnir which fetches around 2-2.5 n i think so there’s 9.5 n + the red x pps (.25 n) so that’s 9.75 n and i’m not sure about the items but I didn’t see any that have high demand / are worth much. I think there may be some from 2009 so that’ll be a couple of ‘09 rares but not enough to make another .25 n or anything.
Edit: I didn’t see the other red x pps so their side is 10n in total
Edit again: Their side is actually 10.5 n

[Leek.dot]

Could anyone please give me some help?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=96470217&userid=990178&signature=EVf_ffS5OObXJ-EeC2UisQ
Thank you in advance!

[Rbpuppy]

was this fair .-.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96444030&userid=358339&signature=GOB_FRn0DrZ6cCCD6yjetA

I Know the monster eyes are from 2010

the red monster eyes are worth .25n and their side is worth 2 ma so they were under by 1-2 MA

Agreed, it was unfair to you

[fishymcstix]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96443457&userid=299067&signature=IJj-NkdGsbBGxA52j4wG4w

thoughts? it’s a litter swap but i’m hesitant because i’m not sure if one of them is more valuable than the other or if they’re about the same. any help would be appreciated <3