The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread - Please use this one!

[Yammie]

Need to know if I'm being fair to myself or very unfair to myself. Person sends a suggestion and while my rules say to not send any under any circumstances, trying to get the remaining event pets is fine. They ask what I'm willing to offer and I sent it back, as a suggestion, with said amount. Am I being unfair to myself doing this? Do they need to add on more to compensate for the amount of C$ I'm willing to give for the pets?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yGOMDViZoA

Anyone?

we can't see what you're offering.

[jinixe]

which is better?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... je5qYN_JzA
or

[billie eilish]

Is this fair?

[sasha is quitting]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=31327712&userid=181626&signature=dR_KU_RcgCz5pgN_4GpHVA

help plz? ive been getting a lot of trades for 2010 uncommons like the malks and warrior cats, would really like to know whats a good trade for them

I would say it's unfair for them...

{looks unfair to the bottom to me

so one opinion says unfair to them, meaning unfair the person offering the rares?

but another says unfair to the bottom, meaning unfair to me (the side with the malk fox + dragon butterfly)?

please help, im very confused which way to go!

[hyena.]

Is this fair?

Unfair too you;; the rat with the items should be fair

[sasha is quitting]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=31327712&userid=181626&signature=dR_KU_RcgCz5pgN_4GpHVA

help plz? ive been getting a lot of trades for 2010 uncommons like the malks and warrior cats, would really like to know whats a good trade for them

I would say it's unfair for them...

{looks unfair to the bottom to me

so one opinion says unfair to them, meaning unfair the person offering the rares?

but another says unfair to the bottom, meaning unfair to me (the side with the malk fox + dragon butterfly)?

please help, im very confused which way to go!

[alchemist.]

="Crazy Cat Lindsay"]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a6xVe9Eh-g
Demand wise to please!

Unfair to them.

Thank!s, could I get a second opinion to be sure?

[/quote][/quote][/quote]
Please?[/quote][/quote]
Please guys? This was from yesterday.

[jinixe]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=31327712&userid=181626&signature=dR_KU_RcgCz5pgN_4GpHVA

help plz? ive been getting a lot of trades for 2010 uncommons like the malks and warrior cats, would really like to know whats a good trade for them

I would say it's unfair for them...

{looks unfair to the bottom to me

so one opinion says unfair to them, meaning unfair the person offering the rares?

but another says unfair to the bottom, meaning unfair to me (the side with the malk fox + dragon butterfly)?

please help, im very confused which way to go![/quote]
Unfair to the bottom,I agree with trouble.

[GreatWhiteDragon_1]

Need to know if I'm being fair to myself or very unfair to myself. Person sends a suggestion and while my rules say to not send any under any circumstances, trying to get the remaining event pets is fine. They ask what I'm willing to offer and I sent it back, as a suggestion, with said amount. Am I being unfair to myself doing this? Do they need to add on more to compensate for the amount of C$ I'm willing to give for the pets?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yGOMDViZoA

Anyone?

we can't see what you're offering.

You should be able to. It's part of the reply message. I'm willing to give 12 C$ for those pets, but if it's grossly unfair to me, then what?

[sasha is quitting]

Unfair to the bottom,I agree with trouble.

...wait, what? trouble say unfair to them, not unfair to bottom

im confused, when you look at someone elses trade, does the top/bottom get swapped from when youre looking at your own?