The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Kadmos]

is this fair? i know it's worth 680, but has it gone for anything higher? i'm saving it for a myo for a species and they only want the lowest price of it but if it goes for higher i'd like to know...

Honestly so far ive seen two users selling theyr yellow toxics for that price so i think its fair but i also encourage you to seek one more opinion before accepting ^^

[LordDarkMist]

Is this fair, if not how can it be made fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907193&userid=614219&signature=96oAPFkvSq1Y5Yaf4pDVIw
Any help appreciated.
What if the items were removed?

[SeaCrest]

Thoughts on these, please?

one

[Redpanda]

Oof i’m not sure about this.


Ahh it’s a pretty direct swap but could I get some opinions before accepting?

[Foxed]

is this a fair trade? i'm not very good with items!

*edit
and this one?? i know i have some older items in there, but not too sure about demand! especially on the mermaid tails?

Personally i think this is unfair to you, that cowboy pss costume is from 2011 Haloween. From what i heard Haloween costumes can go from a 2011 uncommon to a rare and despite that the other items are small- flower details theyr pets are common and very commons from 2018 so definetely unfair to you because they wouldnt add up together for that items itself.

Please also seek one more opinion ^^

thank you for your help!

could i get a second opinion on these please?

[Namida_☾]

I don’t think this is fair but I’d like a second opinion and to know how this would be fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83957420&userid=935123&signature=tfLBC4ivtCUpVJhgREzy4Q

[Paul.]

I don’t think this is fair but I’d like a second opinion and to know how this would be fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83957420&userid=935123&signature=tfLBC4ivtCUpVJhgREzy4Q

Very unfair to you. 2015 store pets are only worth a 2009 or 2008 rare at most, so a 2019 store pet would be worth far less than what they asked for on your side.

[SeaCrest]

I don’t think this is fair but I’d like a second opinion and to know how this would be fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83957420&userid=935123&signature=tfLBC4ivtCUpVJhgREzy4Q

Very unfair to you. 2015 store pets are only worth a 2009 or 2008 rare at most, so a 2019 store pet would be worth far less than what they asked for on your side.

2019 store pets are generally traded at a mid-2010 rare, for reference!

[Blueberry]

Opinions on this offer? What kind of demand does this dragon have? Would y’all personally take it?

[Namida_☾]

I don’t think this is fair but I’d like a second opinion and to know how this would be fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83957420&userid=935123&signature=tfLBC4ivtCUpVJhgREzy4Q

Very unfair to you. 2015 store pets are only worth a 2009 or 2008 rare at most, so a 2019 store pet would be worth far less than what they asked for on your side.

2019 store pets are generally traded at a mid-2010 rare, for reference!

Thank you very much for the quick replies!!<3