The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Patch.]

is this fair

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sVE26GqM9Q

Unfair to you.

[Cornishninja]

Fair? I'm not certain at all how many newborns and this months equals a 2009 uncommon event doggeh D:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RES2fmwEQQ

[bnom]

Okay, thanks a lot!
Is this fair? I don't know about items ^-^

[RascalKeen]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DmVy1husuQ

[Angel Daiyu]

Trade One
Trade Two
Trade Three

I need someone who knows the Rares list very well (I'm looking out for specific users to answer as well; will not tell which ones), and I need more than one person answering (as I'll be able to pick my answer from what the majority picks.

Also, keep in mind that the cerbs are all the good fodder I have left (I have 2 orange and 1 red), and while one of the offers has one of my dreamies, I'm trying to climb to another pet so I can get ALL my dreamies as opposed to having just one.

Should I go for any of these trades?

[Furiouswolf]

would this be fair? are the uncommon pets making up for the month gap between the rares? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ETvkIgtyHQ

[Lively..]

Is this fair? Yes I know their pet is one tier higher than mine but I would like to take demand into place as well. Thanks!

[wye]

Fair or not?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CiEk2_er-w

[Shinigami.]

Fair or not?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CiEk2_er-w

Not fair for bottom I say

[bnom]

Trade One
Trade Two
Trade Three

I need someone who knows the Rares list very well (I'm looking out for specific users to answer as well; will not tell which ones), and I need more than one person answering (as I'll be able to pick my answer from what the majority picks.

Also, keep in mind that the cerbs are all the good fodder I have left (I have 2 orange and 1 red), and while one of the offers has one of my dreamies, I'm trying to climb to another pet so I can get ALL my dreamies as opposed to having just one.

Should I go for any of these trades?

1. Unfair to them, but demand-wise, I wouldn't take it..
2. Unfair to them, the September is higher by 4 tiers. But the dog doesn't have good demand.
3. Should be fair, if not, unfair to them.
Get another opinion ^^;

@Furiouswolf,
Unfair to them ^^;


Is this fair? I don't know about items ^-^