The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85096429&userid=879393&signature=xJrYFMUq6FZLBkjTAI28JQ


Is this fair or should I add more older Rares to my side?

Yeah, you'll need to whack another '10 rare onto your side at the least. C; the full set of store pets is worth two mid '09 rares.

[cαtαstrσphe]

Opinions?

Bad, very bad.
Raven and Sunback are both 2 nons.
Cerb is 3-4 nons, dog tag 2 nons, plus the sorb. I'd trade the cerb and sorb alone for those two.

[phxyvi]

Opinions?

Bad, very bad.
Raven and Sunback are both 2 nons.
Cerb is 3-4 nons, dog tag 2 nons, plus the sorb. I'd trade the cerb and sorb alone for those two.

I would agree it’s a bad trade, but the raven gets two nons and the sunback regularly goes for 3

The dog tag I value at 2 but it hasn’t seen many trades lately so idk
And the cerb @ three. At the least you’re over by .5-1 non

[XxDragonScalesxX]

What about these 2? :3 Any advice on any of them is gladly accepted c:

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=85095990&userid=67531&signature=F80JZ1HrdCpteq7V13a3mw

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=85096129&userid=67531&signature=EOU1k1I3lbcz9q00nCG58A

1. I personally wouldn't take this trade but depending on how you value everything this could be fair or unfair to the other person. The weretomato can get a 2010 uncommon to 09 rare, the nick balloon is worth a 2010 uncommon, and the nick cake can get a 2010 uncommon to rare. All animal eggs are worth a uncommon from their release year except for 1-4 and all the other items are worth uncommons from their release year. So your side is worth about 3.5-5.5 2010 rares or about 3 2010 rares and a 2010 uncommon to 5 2010 rares and a 2010 uncommon.

2. The other person would be overpaying. Your side adds up to about a 2010 rare at max and the only item that might be worth more than a uncommon from it's release year is the fairy and that's depends on who you're trading. At max the fairy would be worth a 2013 rare and the stars can go for a common to uncommon from 2016 each. The rest of the items are worth an uncommon from their release year.

[polyphon]

is this fair?
thanks for any help !!

and this?

[bleak.]

if i value my Phoenix at 1.5 nons, is this fair? Thanks in advance !

[amarok.]

What about these 2? :3 Any advice on any of them is gladly accepted c:

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=85095990&userid=67531&signature=F80JZ1HrdCpteq7V13a3mw

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=85096129&userid=67531&signature=EOU1k1I3lbcz9q00nCG58A

1. I personally wouldn't take this trade but depending on how you value everything this could be fair or unfair to the other person. The weretomato can get a 2010 uncommon to 09 rare, the nick balloon is worth a 2010 uncommon, and the nick cake can get a 2010 uncommon to rare. All animal eggs are worth a uncommon from their release year except for 1-4 and all the other items are worth uncommons from their release year. So your side is worth about 3.5-5.5 2010 rares or about 3 2010 rares and a 2010 uncommon to 5 2010 rares and a 2010 uncommon.

2. The other person would be overpaying. Your side adds up to about a 2010 rare at max and the only item that might be worth more than a uncommon from it's release year is the fairy and that's depends on who you're trading. At max the fairy would be worth a 2013 rare and the stars can go for a common to uncommon from 2016 each. The rest of the items are worth an uncommon from their release year.

i'd actually like to drop in and say that the medival faire gown can easily fetch an '11 rare these days. i think i'd still take it but just a little extra info there.

[elnachos]

how is this looking?

any second opinions?

I don't know why others are thinking that the other side is overpaying, but It's slightly unfair to you, the C$ adds up to a spotted tribal (2 sorbets) and the gearback tribal is 1 tier lower than a sorbet. The non is worth 3 sorbets so you're overpaying by a dark leopard.[/quote]

shsjdkh any last opinions?? been asking for like 9 pages now :'0

[Rbpuppy]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=85096058&userid=939927&signature=-sDix7mHEO4K2VxYIug4NQ

Unfair to you even though the rat may not have the best demand.

[Redpanda]

What about this? Or replace the Green liontail for a non jeweled liontail.