The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ghoull]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85079330&userid=892431&signature=EG1yMokN4qAYFwhFulx-EA

i’m really needing help with this.

[Huggles]

Is this fair?

NOpe, they want a bunch of warrior cats, yet what they want to give you is only worth two of them

Unless im missing something-i very much disagree. That looks like massive overpay on their side, sure sitting cats have good demand, but those arent warrior cats and are generally just worth the 3 month rule.

[amarok.]

Is this fair?

NOpe, they want a bunch of warrior cats, yet what they want to give you is only worth two of them

strong disagree. please don't give vague and inaccurate advice. those aren't warrior cats and the top side is worth roughly twice what the bottom is worth, just by eyeballing it.

even if they were warrior cats, due to the fact they had an extended release they're technically not always even worth what the pet's date would dictate - for example, the 2009 warriors had an extended release into 2010 (april? off of the top of my head?), so are only worth an early '10 rare. the '08 kitters are similar in that they're only technically worth a '09 vr. if you personally choose to offer daft overpay for warriors, that's your choice.

edit two; apparently i am incapable of spelling "example".

[Spottedhyenaaa]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=85096058&userid=939927&signature=-sDix7mHEO4K2VxYIug4NQ

[cαtαstrσphe]

Is this fair? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85096058

Wrong link, use the one at the bottom of the page c:

[Paddi]

What about these 2? :3 Any advice on any of them is gladly accepted c:

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=85095990&userid=67531&signature=F80JZ1HrdCpteq7V13a3mw

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=85096129&userid=67531&signature=EOU1k1I3lbcz9q00nCG58A

[Spottedhyenaaa]

Is this fair? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85096058

Wrong link, use the one at the bottom of the page c:

oop thanks )

[floor.]

Could someone give me some advice on this trade for a drink me? I think I'm a bit under, but not sure if the quantity makes up for it a little? Thanks for any help ^^

[amarok.]

Could someone give me some advice on this trade for a drink me? I think I'm a bit under, but not sure if the quantity makes up for it a little? Thanks for any help ^^

you're quite a bit under, unfortunately. the drink me goes for 5-6 nons i'm told, whereas your side would top out at around 4ish nons in my personal opinion.

[Zelfie]

Anyone know if this is fair for sorb?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85089401&userid=921063&signature=9C6SQvvcuIpndTmrWAQuoA

please help <3