The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[owenwyatt01]

Is this fair and what is mine worth? Thanks!!!!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93149632&userid=989463&signature=ctdrAmxirzzBdd9aYGNdLw

[Karcrab]

opinions on this?

[Rosario.]

so i just got this trade offer after my ladt post here and i don’t even know what to say

trade

is animal egg 2 really worth that much???? i feel like i’d be crazy to decline but also i have no idea what i’m doing, someone please help? i’m not used to high value trading at ALL aaaaaa

edit: i just got sent this one too and i’m freaking out??? i’m so not used to trading things like this please help me

According to the item guide eggs 1-4 value around an 08 pet each. With eggs 1-2 being valued at an august 08, and 3-4 being a september 08. How the pets you're being offered measure up to that value I'm not entirely sure, but at least the item guide helps to get an idea of the value! c:

Edit: Looking through the search function on this thread past answers have valued 1-2 in nons. Look up 'animal egg' on the search function to see those answers.

[Denidene]

Heya, holding an auction for token and was wondering what bid was the best quality wise？

bid a + this + this

bid b + this + this

bid c

On a side note, how does very rare to rare work in a 2:1 rule? Or does that not apply? (could not find information on this anywhere)

Thank you so much in advance! <3

Someone please help, auction ends in less than 2 hours and I don't know what to do 😭

[In The Darke]

so i just got this trade offer after my ladt post here and i don’t even know what to say

trade

is animal egg 2 really worth that much???? i feel like i’d be crazy to decline but also i have no idea what i’m doing, someone please help? i’m not used to high value trading at ALL aaaaaa

edit: i just got sent this one too and i’m freaking out??? i’m so not used to trading things like this please help me

From what I remember Animal Egg 2 is considered worth a non at the very least, but that could be old info and items don't get re-released so it wouldn't shock me if users were offering 2+. Personally I'd hold off for an irresistible offer, its value can only go up and item collectors need the first 4 eggs, plus they're a popular item set. Maybe even advertise on your trade thread if you have one, or even your signature/trade rules (:

[iHolli]

{very uncertain what to do with this; it feels like a lot on my side, but I'm just not sure. Am I underpaying? Overpaying?}
× trade

.Holli.

this trade is very unfair to you.
just the store pets alone would be fair for the rare on their side. However it depends on how you value the '21 store pets as they are worth a late '10 rare - an early '11 rare. But even then, it wouldn't be fair to you. Also in my opinion, the pets on your side have better demand than their pet as spiders are harder to trade off.
please get a second opinion.

{oh thank you !! This is a lot of help, I still thought new store pet sets were worth an 09 rare so this is useful insight asdkkg}
{Reposting to get that second opinion! ^^}

{Also have this one as well; I'm certain I'm underpaying but want to be sure what's happening!}
trade ×2

.Holli.

[Karcrab]

opinions on this?

[Guest]

Is this fair?
Thank you in advance!

oops also this
Thank you again!

[Rosario.]

Heya, holding an auction for token and was wondering what bid was the best quality wise？

bid a + this + this

bid b + this + this

bid c

On a side note, how does very rare to rare work in a 2:1 rule? Or does that not apply? (could not find information on this anywhere)

Thank you so much in advance! <3

Someone please help, auction ends in less than 2 hours and I don't know what to do 😭

I'd say look at these quotes talking about token values vs pet values and then work out which fits.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93130605&userid=675207&signature=eoOWk4b0vug1-EFQ5FTTEw

I'm really confused on this. I'm not sure it's fair. Each token is worth 2 cs$ each so that racks over 200 cs$ and from what I believe each 2009/ 2010 rare is worth 40 or 50 cs$. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

you're completely right
this is majorly unfair to you

[AyyeItsKelsey]

Is this fair?
Thank you in advance!

oops also this
Thank you again!

For the second one, I checked in the pet worth thread and the skeleton bun goes for 10-12 nons. From a different thread (a list thread with demand, etc) it says that the bee is 2.5-3.5 since there is 4, putting it worth the lowest (2.5) It would come out to 10 nons, then the drink me is 6 non again according to the pet worth thread. They would be overpaying by quite a bit I believe. Anyone feel free to correct me if im wrong