The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread - Please use this one!

[cats12378]

Sorry for being a derp, I had a long day and brain no work. This is a fair trade right? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... cZT5tj0Brg

There both the same year, and I think like a few months apart. I think I remember this being fair but can't remember.

Pleas and thanks.

I don't think it's fair because your dog is a nick,making it rarer to some,but not all
Its just like too people adopted pets today,one a malk,one a cat if they traded,the person with malk would think malk as a rarer pet

[cats12378]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=31343197&userid=270254&signature=b1dfKcpaNTvbknQaicm0KQ

Is this fair? I have a feeling it's not, because these are '11 pets and all of the ones they're offering are '13 pets, but I just want to make sure here.

Yup 11 pets are rarer then 2013,plus their rarities are unfair too

[ElevatingHearts]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HZ9Mj4_S9g

[cats12378]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=31343288&userid=399376&signature=G6q_MYMxFeNZ7HA-InNHlQ

Was that fair? Just to get a second opinion.

The horse is 2011,so I don't think a vodoo costume is fair enough

[cats12378]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=31343843&userid=300718&signature=edLk-8kiPhcpHZ9Mj4_S9g

Should be fair,but to most bunnies are rarer then rats

[korok]

How many more C$ would make this fair.

[cats12378]

How many more C$ would make this fair.

I already thinks its a HUGE overtrade

[Elfa]

This trade probably isn't fair to them, but which of theirs should I remove to make it fair?

[cats12378]

This trade probably isn't fair to them, but which of theirs should I remove to make it fair?

The chicken

[ElevatingHearts]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=31343843&userid=300718&signature=edLk-8kiPhcpHZ9Mj4_S9g

Should be fair,but to most bunnies are rarer then rats

Second opinion, please?
Also, cats, please remember to not post one post right after the other. There is the ability to edit a post for a reason. Also, you can reply to several people in one post. Please do not fill up the form with posts one right after the other as it can become harder to find our replies, and it kind of spams it up a bit.