The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ImThatRogue]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63506742&userid=850357&signature=PbEIdXXkldS7q87Vb-0P0Q
How fair is this bid?
Thanks!

It's unfair to them. Their '12 re-released dog is from early '09 and their '13 re-released bunny is from early '10. Therefore just the '13 re-released bunny, '10 cat, and '12 re-released dog would be fine, if not slightly unfair to you because your dog is from early '09. The other rares make it pretty unfair to them.

[BlizzardTheWizard]

Hey! Is this fair..? I need an answer quick please! I'm trading for the pocky!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jLO0q5gLOw

[dvnc]

Hello! I am rusty on item trades... Any opinions are helpful! x (The nick horse is from 2009)

[BlizzardTheWizard]

Hey! Is this fair..? I need an answer quick please! I'm trading for the pocky!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jLO0q5gLOw

[Hauntednightmares]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63501141&userid=867096&signature=0bjt37aj5F4Ic459ZXZuhA
I got this. I value raven at 2 soberts to a non. I value BEG from 1 non to 1.5 nons
what's your opinion.

[hummxs]

Hey! Is this fair..? I need an answer quick please! I'm trading for the pocky!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jLO0q5gLOw

Please only post once per page. Posting multiple times counts as spam.

I believe it's unfair to you as the pocky is worth a late '08 very rare, which your two very rares add up to, so the other pets aren't necessary.

[bluebird.]

Which offer would you accept?
♦ or ♦
Personally, I prefer the first one, but a second opinion would be great.
Thanks for any help in advance!

[pink]

Which offer would you accept?
♦ or ♦
Personally, I prefer the first one, but a second opinion would be great.
Thanks for any help in advance!

Personally I would not accept any of them due to the cats having an INSANE demand and they are all/almost all from 2009, even with the first trade having a list in it I find it unfair.

[Horror]

Which offer would you accept?
♦ or ♦
Personally, I prefer the first one, but a second opinion would be great.
Thanks for any help in advance!

I'd take the first one, the second one is worth much less compared to it. Rarity wise it's unfair to them though, your side is only worth about 17 09 rares + almost a '10 rare & a cake dog alone is worth around 42.
Demand wise depends how you value the warriors though.

[Rain;;]

demand wise would UR grapes + Blue Balloon dog get me the Raven?