CS Items Guide - Help update values - Medieval Faire Tokens

[Solloby]

Double posting so my ramblings aren't mixed up with the stuff I'll be copy & pasting onto the front page eventually ^^;

I'm unhappy with the formatting of the Rares List Items section so I'll have to work out something easier to do with it. The poor little Halo gets lost because of the huge sets above and below it.

Noleah lol that's a lot of trades
I think my only notable trade recently is this one (they forgot to ask for the teeth from the set but I sent them along after accepting the trade): http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0fyaoLJSPA

I have revised the DIY Cake Set value to Balloon Dog - Green Toxic, down from Balloon Dog - Red Toxic. People just don't seem to be trading for the cake set so I am open to shifting its value further. It is a ridiculously rare item though, it'd be OMGSR as a set.

[Solloby]

I've added the late 09 rare items to the above post. Questions for everyone:

1. Do you agree with the placement of the 09 rare/vr items in the above post?
I am a little unsure about some of the late ones. Those plushies are popular and hard to come by; I am not sure the candy tokens & eggs would go for that value each but then again I never see them in anyone's inventories anymore so ?

2. Do you think any of these items should go up into the late 09 rare/vr section:

Mid 09 Uncommon
08 Merry Christmas
09 CS 1st Birthday Black Anniversary Bow
09 CS 1st Birthday Red Anniversary Bow
09 CS 1st Birthday Cake Slices
09 St Patrick's Day Socks
09 St Patrick's Day Boots
09 Rainbow Tess Birthday Sign
09 Thanksgiving Turkey Plushie
09 Thanksgiving Cooked Turkey Dinner (Plated)
09 Halloween Green Lil Monster
09 Halloween Ghosties
09 Halloween Candy Bags
09 Santa Dress
09 Christmas Pyjamas
09 Christmas Elf Hats & Boots
09 Candy Cane Lil Monster
09 Christmas Mini Stockings
09 Christmas Large Stockings
09 Christmas Partridge in a Pear Tree
09 Christmas Three French Hens
09 Christmas Two Turtle Doves

10 Rare
10 Store Halloween Monster Eyes - Early 2010 Rare
11 Medieval Faire Elven Set

[ferncat]

Where is the 09 Black Cat Pony item to be set?
I couldn't seem to find it here:
[removed]

[Solloby]

The pony costume was always missing off the list, it was never valued. But yes it should definitely be in there somewhere.


Where should it be placed? Early 09 rare/vr section? I never see it around. I paid art for mine and have been unable to find any trades with it, but when I was searching for it, it was difficult to find. It was retired in 2011 I think; maybe mid 09 for the set? Or early?

Please don't quote the giant image post though ^^;

[Takora Drakan]

An early 09 or even mid/late 09 VR sounds good for the pony costume, considering the spiked demand that it fits now all ponies.

[Celozon]

I in particular have noticed that the Malk fairies, Totoro Plushie, and the Store Winter Scarves are all fairly popular and hard to come by. I've found them all much harder to find and get then the Malk plushies. I think the fairies at least should be moved up, I've been offered and paid more than a late '09 rare for them multiple times. And I personally probably wouldn't accept a late '09 rare for them unless it was something popular.

I'd also vote for the 09 Halloween Ghosties and the 10 Store Halloween Monster Eyes to be placed in the '09 section. I've never been able to find any monster eyes for trade and I'd personally be happy to offer more than a late '09 rare for them if I did find them, and the ghosts have decent popularity and aren't easy to come by. I know I've been offered an '09 rare for them before.

The elven set also has pretty good popularity, but I've found its not really a rare item, the hard part is just collecting all the pieces. I've had multiple full sets at a time, which is more than I can say for a lot of other items I've been looking for.

[Solloby]

I've updated the draft on the previous page: viewtopic.php?f=20&t=559754&start=880#p56182142

Items added/changed:

Black Cat Pony outfit
09 Animal Eggs
Totoro Plushie
Store Winter Scarves (I've also been paid very well for these when I had spares, I was cleaned out of them very fast)
Malk Fairies
Monster Eyes
Ghosties

I am wondering if these guys, or a couple of them, should be shifted to Mid? Or are they fine in Late?


The only other items I am considering placing in the Late 09 Rare section are:

Turkey Plushie
Halloween Green Lil Monster
Elf Hats & Boots (hat + boot pair) - I had a bit of trouble finding these myself
Candy Cane Lil Monster
Two Turtle Doves
And maybe some of the other 09 Christmas stuff, I'm unsure.

Agree that the Eleven Set is probably ok to stay in the 2010 section. It can be noted as a high demand item set.

[ferncat]

I've updated the draft on the previous page: viewtopic.php?f=20&t=559754&start=880#p56182142

Items added/changed:

Black Cat Pony outfit
09 Animal Eggs
Totoro Plushie
Store Winter Scarves (I've also been paid very well for these when I had spares, I was cleaned out of them very fast)
Malk Fairies
Monster Eyes
Ghosties

I am wondering if these guys, or a couple of them, should be shifted to Mid? Or are they fine in Late?


The only other items I am considering placing in the Late 09 Rare section are:

Turkey Plushie
Halloween Green Lil Monster
Elf Hats & Boots (hat + boot pair) - I had a bit of trouble finding these myself
Candy Cane Lil Monster
Two Turtle Doves
And maybe some of the other 09 Christmas stuff, I'm unsure.

Agree that the Eleven Set is probably ok to stay in the 2010 section. It can be noted as a high demand item set.

I find that the dog,cat and zebra plushies are hard to find, and feel that they should be shifted up. But other people may think otherwise.

[ratius]

Mid 09 Rare / Very Rare

The following items are worth approximately the same amount and are listed in no particular order.

Individual Items


Malk Sitting Dog Plushies (each) - Christmas 2009

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/archive/2010/CS%202nd%20Bday/Items/

Hi! The guide is looking great so far! Although I don't see the orange and green dog in these plushies, seen in the archive link below the image... But it is worth the same as the other sitting malk plushies right?

[Solloby]

Thanks Ferncat. Does anyone else have thoughts on those plushies and the list of items?

Ratius - fixed, thanks for picking it up c: