The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Animall]

I've been told sunjewel has a bad demand? So would this be fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78287573&userid=160999&signature=Vgs1Q1vjIRkLyOdy4RhL_Q

The sunjewel doesn’t have bad demand. It has pretty average demand, it just trades unfairly because it’s high on the list and it’s hard to find people with enough trade fodder.
Unfair to you. The dog tag does have bad demand and trades for less than it’s value. You can get way better.

[Targaryen]

I've been told sunjewel has a bad demand? So would this be fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78287573&userid=160999&signature=Vgs1Q1vjIRkLyOdy4RhL_Q

The sunjewel doesn’t have bad demand. It has pretty average demand, it just trades unfairly because it’s high on the list and it’s hard to find people with enough trade fodder.
Unfair to you. The dog tag does have bad demand and trades for less than it’s value. You can get way better.

this ^
the dog-tag is plagued by the same high-list "bad demand" so has the same sort of issue.

[chihirofujisaki]

Does anyone have an opinion on this bid for my dogtag?

[Relara]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78310388&userid=698931&signature=ZrM1kWnhAQMgKlA7A1D7YA

[Reirin]

thoughts on this trade? thanks <3

[Targaryen]

opinions?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78310388&userid=698931&signature=ZrM1kWnhAQMgKlA7A1D7YA would

1.
2
3
4
5. or replace sorb+balloon with TD BMD
6.
7

advice with experience in both rarity and common demand values only please <3

[Potoooooooo]

help with this one?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78173534&userid=658664&signature=K4Uga-r_L8a2DFevrqIVhg
thanks

help?

please? some help?

[sundayskies]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78302020&userid=756356&signature=MFGNTpKEipwMFTNqn0EBrw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78312349&userid=756356&signature=AZ-00BsGwOHG0UdsWCygaw
are either of these fair?

[xXPizzaCatPrincessXx]

AH which one should i do if any at all?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78310888&userid=858203&signature=fUQfGcCuJDMzIGFOQivXWA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78307171&userid=858203&signature=ZE5kYJBQgrCu_UncEbNmeQ

The GWJ (with demand) can typically get around 1.5-2 Sorbets the rat right now can get one sorbet, until it's settled where it will be placed on the list.
The HSR (with demand) can get around a high Sept//t1 main list. I would personally go with the GWJ trade. If anything I have said is wrong, I apologise, I'm basing it off of recent trades I've seen.

[Targaryen]

AH which one should i do if any at all?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78310888&userid=858203&signature=fUQfGcCuJDMzIGFOQivXWA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78307171&userid=858203&signature=ZE5kYJBQgrCu_UncEbNmeQ

The GWJ (with demand) can typically get around 1.5-2 Sorbets the rat right now can get one sorbet, until it's settled where it will be placed on the list.
The HSR (with demand) can get around a high Sept//t1 main list. I would personally go with the GWJ trade. If anything I have said is wrong, I apologise, I'm basing it off of recent trades I've seen.

agree c: