closed! go to new thread!

[Little Tiggy]

Update on my Zodiac offers!

1. This is the original overpay trade I asked about.

2. This is a newer offer.

I realize that #1 is much more unfair to the person offering an overpayment, and that #2 is much more fair for the other player in comparison.

But if it were you, which trade would you accept?

#1 is worth around 2-4 09 rares, #2 is worth 3-4 ^^ also the malk cats tend to have good demand!

So which one would you accept? I know both of them are great offers.

1. Great overpayment
The rarities are a tradeup
But the dates are off

2. Great offer
Dates

[Dymestl]

xXx

This was the trade beforehand, then they edited and added 60 items (some of them being store items). I'm trying to avoid having so many items.

[linnbergg]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7yzhaBAmAw

How is it demand wise?

[ToxicHoundour]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=50931828&userid=58286&signature=f5OnU_wkx7wnNbHK76IagQ got this as a bid in my auction unsure if it would be the new top bid

this is the current top http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hEzwnwcl9A

Thank you

can anyone please help?

[Kaidaft]

which bid is better?

Bid 1- the boar is a normal 2009 rare, so is the cat

Bid 2

That's actually a boar '09 rare from earlier in 2009, not the GUPPS of christmas '09

so.. any decisions, guys? the boar IS a regular 2009 rare, i checked in the archives...

The boar is the boar PPS, and is on the list. Some 2009 pets were put onto the rarest list for their equality in value to the ones in 2008

[Ɉѻkҽ℞ keep şмίĻέing?]

is this fair? I think the nick makes it up but not sure...

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kwQeSOnPSA

[Little Tiggy]

Update on my Zodiac offers!

1. This is the original overpay trade I asked about.

2. This is a newer offer.

I realize that #1 is much more unfair to the person offering an overpayment, and that #2 is much more fair for the other player in comparison.

But if it were you, which trade would you accept?

#1 is worth around 2-4 09 rares, #2 is worth 3-4 ^^ also the malk cats tend to have good demand!

So which one would you accept? I know both of them are great offers.

1. Great overpayment
The rarities are a tradeup
But the dates are off

2. Great offer
Dates

[BB-8]

UR Aussie = pps malk dragon + ?

I have no clue what the pps dragon goes for demand wise.
Thanks in advance for any help!

[linnbergg]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7yzhaBAmAw

How is it demand wise?

[/quote]

[deletedaccountbye]

Is this fair?? Please help!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dYhtGtz9Mg