The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[The Black Cat]

Is this fair:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u_247xN3Zg

For this?

[Nebulava]

Is this fair:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0585&useri

For this?

You used the wrong link. Please use the link listed under the [Share Trade] button

[Kyar]

Is this fair? If not, do you have the slightest idea of what should be done to it? Thank you for your time. ^^

It's unfair to them. :) The malk dragon is only worth about 42 09 rares and with the advents and massive quantity on their side it's asking too much. :)
Edit:
Looking again their side could get a main list pet so it's quite unfair to them. :)

[Twister in Rage]

1 Shima butterfly wolf and 1 shima longtail? would that be fair?

If you're talking about the Dark Shima B-Wolf, it's extremely unfair to the Butterfly Wolf.

[katespets]

Is this fair? If not, do you have the slightest idea of what should be done to it? Thank you for your time. ^^

Wow, that is a massive trade! Extremely unfair to the top side. Must be desperate for a Malk Dragon. XD

Please dont give false information. If we include demand, it is unfair to the dragon because it is on the rares' list.

I believe it's unfair to the top, not to the dragon. They have a lot of good quality VRs and rares in there.

[RandomSia]

How fair is this? Not sure how the uncommon 2013-2011 transfer would work.
Fair or not?
Thanks ahead of time!

[Nebulava]

How fair is this? Not sure how the uncommon 2013-2011 transfer would work.
Fair or not?
Thanks ahead of time!

Looks pretty fair to me, if not just slightly unfair to you, by a couple commons

[Kyar]

How fair is this? Not sure how the uncommon 2013-2011 transfer would work.
Fair or not?
Thanks ahead of time!

Looks pretty fair to me, if not just slightly unfair to you, by a couple commons

Eh - I'd say it's a bit unfair to them. An 11 uncommon could get you a 13 rare. :)

[bvrd]

fair?

[Febuh]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... pTu4qJMY8Q
fair??