The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[matthew patel]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105252817&userid=1074987&signature=vN0WuKW546CD8Acn3tEqLQ
idk, mate, this trade just seems too good to be true

Definitely overpay, it's just up to you on whether you really want to keep your dragon or not.

thank you, dude! i wasn’t sure if the dragon had secret value or not that i was unaware of SHSNSNDHGNDN

[Lex.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105252817&userid=1074987&signature=vN0WuKW546CD8Acn3tEqLQ
idk, mate, this trade just seems too good to be true

Definitely overpay, it's just up to you on whether you really want to keep your dragon or not.

thank you, dude! i wasn’t sure if the dragon had secret value or not that i was unaware of SHSNSNDHGNDN

Ofc, and I get it! I myself have had to look up some values, I recently came back from a semi-hiatus lol

[keayi]

I am absolutely terrible at understanding values; plus the size of this has me a bit overwhelemed-?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105248768&userid=870682&signature=MOl-pBdCUcfWLLySlt-hYg

1 '10 R
1 '11 UC fair for other '11 UC
2 '12 UC
1 '13 R
4 '14 C (vc included)
2 '14 UC = 1 '13 UC = .5 '12 UC = 1 '12 C fair for '12 C
2 '15 UC (c incl) = 4 '16 UC = 8 '16 C
------- EVERYTHING BELOW THIS LINE = 43 '19 UC (working backwards) (~32 '19 UC in overpay)
2 '16 R (vc,c, uc incl) = 8 '19 UC
8.5 '17 C (vc incl) = 17 '19 UC
12 '18 VC = 6 '19 UC
4 '18 C = 4 '19 UC
2 '18 UC = 4 '19 UC
2 '19 C = 1 '19 UC
3 '19 UC

For:
1 '11 UC fair for other '11 UC
1 '12 C fair for 2 '14 UC
1 '16 C
------- EVERYTHING BELOW THIS LINE = 11 '19 UC (working backwards)
1 '17 UC = 4 '19 UC
2 '18 VC = .5 '19 UC
1 '18 UC = 2 '19 UC
2 '19 VC = .25 '19 UC
3 '21 UC = 1.5 '20 UC = .75 '19 UC
38 '23 C = 19 '23 UC = 9.5 '22 UC = 4.75 '21 UC = 2.4 '20 UC = 1.2 '19 UC
38 '23 UC = 19 '22 UC = 9.5 '21 UC = 4.75 '20 UC = 2.4 '19 UC

I might have messed up somewhere in this mess but in general, they're overpaying! (Everything italicized is overpay). These are jus the hardnumbers, but when it comes to very commons-uncommons, most people trade based on gut-feeling and what they're okay with giving and recieving. I think its unfair for them to trade off the '10 R and couple '12 UCs, personally, but maybe they're chill with it. Just something to think about.

[Mistwing]

Is this trade fair?

[mymelody<3]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105254456&userid=1064257&signature=Iz-An9KcpqjqukfwlWm5IA
Hi! Is this fair? Tysm to any help in advance !♡

[Lex.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105254456&userid=1064257&signature=Iz-An9KcpqjqukfwlWm5IA
Hi! Is this fair? Tysm to any help in advance !♡

Unfair to you, their side boils down to about 5 09 rares, while the rats are about 1 MA each.

[mymelody<3]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105254456&userid=1064257&signature=Iz-An9KcpqjqukfwlWm5IA
Hi! Is this fair? Tysm to any help in advance !♡

Unfair to you, their side boils down to about 5 09 rares, while the rats are about 1 MA each.

Okay thank you that is what I was thinking. Have an amazing day!♡

[Squecca]

Sorry for all the trades and I think most of them can be easy, but i don't feel like thinking right now. Can I please have some help? thank you!!! <3
1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105050552&userid=1026562&signature=Cru2lrDVtlpTAzNBCBh-wQ
2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105117509&userid=1026562&signature=m2HAH9k6RjinHZeOJ4-1Ww
3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105184637&userid=1026562&signature=ZBveBRCs4jccD82rVKvKqQ
4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105240479&userid=1026562&signature=VLzYbYdejeyEz4r8lyGOOw
5. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105240867&userid=1026562&signature=PXe2SNzsp-fRYvJiJLuHXg
6. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105254715&userid=1026562&signature=Y_lfcC9mPCZkWTECos66Dg
7. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105255171&userid=1026562&signature=tTO5kcJe_QnESh_53Wy7RA

[Lex.]

Sorry for all the trades and I think most of them can be easy, but i don't feel like thinking right now. Can I please have some help? thank you!!! :D <3

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105117509&userid=1026562&signature=m2HAH9k6RjinHZeOJ4-1Ww
3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105184637&userid=1026562&signature=ZBveBRCs4jccD82rVKvKqQ
4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105240479&userid=1026562&signature=VLzYbYdejeyEz4r8lyGOOw
6. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105254715&userid=1026562&signature=Y_lfcC9mPCZkWTECos66Dg
7. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105255171&userid=1026562&signature=tTO5kcJe_QnESh_53Wy7RA

2 - underpay on their side
3- fair, and a bit overpay since dogs are more popular with demand.
4 - i'd say overpay on their side for now, as their pet is older but LN pets and dragons are usually more liked.
6 - was for sure unfair for you, and so was 7

[Squecca]

Sorry for all the trades and I think most of them can be easy, but i don't feel like thinking right now. Can I please have some help? thank you!!! <3

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105117509&userid=1026562&signature=m2HAH9k6RjinHZeOJ4-1Ww
3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105184637&userid=1026562&signature=ZBveBRCs4jccD82rVKvKqQ
4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105240479&userid=1026562&signature=VLzYbYdejeyEz4r8lyGOOw
6. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105254715&userid=1026562&signature=Y_lfcC9mPCZkWTECos66Dg
7. trades/viewtrade.php?id=105255171&userid=1026562&signature=tTO5kcJe_QnESh_53Wy7RA

2 - underpay on their side
3- fair, and a bit overpay since dogs are more popular with demand.
4 - i'd say overpay on their side for now, as their pet is older but LN pets and dragons are usually more liked.
6 - was for sure unfair for you, and so was 7

thank you very very much! <3