The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sluiceway]

What's the current demand like on Malk dragons right now?
Are they really worth advents? I've been super inactive so I have no idea what demand is right now but I don't want it to be unfair to them

edit;;
also which is a better offer on my '08 UR Cat: a Coontail or a Red Cerb +?
also how is this?

The first one is overpay. The Dragon isn't a list, so it's technically worth the three month rule, but some people overpay. And they offered a tier 3 or 4 advent list.

The second one I saw unfair to them because they pineapple is worth 2 sorbets and the ur apple, but usual Goes for less.

Second opinion? And how's the offers on my UR Cat?

[Kittysnyper]

I would just like to make sure all the bulk adds up in this trade

[Fwutter]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sxhqtTzx6g

The top is overpaying slightly. Their malk pps is worth about 40-45 c$. So really they traded you approximately 465-470c$ and the UR apple is only valued at 455c$, which means they overtraded by 10-15c$

but you also may want to note that C$ is very hard to trade it for lists, as not many people seek for the chicken dollars when it comes trading their lists for an amount of them.

I agree ^^. But I didn't state that only because the Apple has bad demand and it's really rare to see it go for overpay, but personally I wouldn't accept this as I value pet more than c$.

[grimwalker]

I would just like to make sure all the bulk adds up in this trade

it depends on how you value a warrior cat, considering the black one is the only real warrior there, and as we know warriors go for decent offers. the other cats don't really have a common knowledge and are mainly about the place here and there, but if you like rarity or bulk then I'm not really sure. maybe you should get a second opinion about the trade?

[luc]

this is unfair to me right? Does their pet have like any special demand? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... oFIc27FNIw

Rarity wise this is completely fair. Demand varies from person to person. I personally have found that the forward facing guinea pigs have good demand.

Thanks. Can I get a second opinion?

I just want to note, even though demand varies from person to person, you can easily get a decent 09 rare for your zodiac. I can't speak for the guinea pig's demand though.

[Silphy]

Is this fair?

[arcanewilde]

Hey I wanted to know is this trade was fair just wondering ;p
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7JAqFUEF6A

[Kittysnyper]

I would just like to make sure all the bulk adds up in this trade

it depends on how you value a warrior cat, considering the black one is the only real warrior there, and as we know warriors go for decent offers. the other cats don't really have a common knowledge and are mainly about the place here and there, but if you like rarity or bulk then I'm not really sure. maybe you should get a second opinion about the trade?

Thanks! Anyone else?

[Silphy]

Is this fair?

[grimwalker]

Hey I wanted to know is this trade was fair just wondering ;p
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7JAqFUEF6A

a '16 rare can catch a '14 uncommon at its worth- but when it comes to rats they don't really have the best demand.