The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Kasaica]

Boar GUPPS
for
Kiss PPS?

[Jeweled]

Boar GUPPS
for
Kiss PPS?

Very unfair to the KISS.

[Kasaica]

Mmkay, thanks! Just checking to make sure.

[Zandalen]

Their side: Red Malk Cerbrus
My side: Pink September 08'

Is this fair? I was looking for the RED, Blue or White Malk Dragon, but before I say okay I want to see if this is fair.

Not even close.

Okay thanks, I'll just hold out until one of those dragon's show up.^^

[Khemo]

for

[EnteHühnchen]

Ok, I'm in a "discussion" with someone who says that 2 Uncommons are worth a Rare. I disagree (although it does depend on the pets and what you're willing to pay but generally speaking). These Rare pets (which I'm assuming they're referring to) are the Grey and White Dragon. The Uncommons (which they have) are '09 (starting December) and '10.

Any opinions?

[emilyg2014]

Zebra
for
Sun Jewel

How much would sun jewel have to add, if anything?

[huskynerd]

Ok, I'm in a "discussion" with someone who says that 2 Uncommons are worth a Rare. I disagree (although it does depend on the pets and what you're willing to pay but generally speaking). These Rare pets (which I'm assuming they're referring to) are the Grey and White Dragon. The Uncommons (which they have) are '09 (starting December) and '10.

Any opinions?

Terribly unsound logic, and there's no way either of those dragons is worth any 2 Uncommons from Dec '09 and 2010. Some rares aren't even worth other rares, there is really no formula - anyone who claims there is is generally full of it.

Zebra
for
Sun Jewel

How much would sun jewel have to add, if anything?

Nothing, it's a fair swap - or the Zebra side might even need to add something.

for

Unfair to the November bobtail.

[Khemo]

for

Unfair to the November bobtail.

Alrighty. Any suggestions on what might be more fair?

[Seasonal]

They offered:
Three Rare rats (All on my Wishlit)
Five Anniversary Cats (Hoard)

They want:
Advent '08 Horse
Rare Green and Orange Butterfly Wolf (October '09)
Rare Purple and Green Rat