The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[remina]

I disagree. Looking at trades in the successful trade thread a RR gets 1 non mostly sometimes 1.5 non with those being outliers. The only august pps that trades for 2 nons is the TD's.

8m just speaking from experience from trading for 3 August pps lions, both trading for and trading away and have gotten 2 nons for RR very easily and 2.5 nons for a TD I would not be taking a non dog for one, I personally just think it's very unfair advice !

This is again another conversation about value pushing in this thread. Even if you CAN find someone who's desperate enough to pay a whole 2 nons for it doesn't mean that should be the standard. All the trade data shows it for 1 to 1.5 nons therefore these trades are fair which is what this thread is about it's not a "can I get a better offer?" thread : /

[SabrinaB]

How is this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110503255&userid=217156&signature=vk_t_QSqauzIVRQ9JwGp5A

There are about 100 pets on their side. No need to count them all up exactly, but just if its close to fair

[Gamezelle]

How is this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110503255&userid=217156&signature=vk_t_QSqauzIVRQ9JwGp5A

There are about 100 pets on their side. No need to count them all up exactly, but just if its close to fair

Unfair to you I think.

The two 2010 rares could be worth your VR.

As for their other pets, it average around a hundred 2019 Commons (and I'm being generous), which even for bulk trading is not fair and way too recent for 2 2010 rares ans 2 2011 rares.

Anyone else has an opinion on this ?

[.:Ciel Phantomhive:.]

I’m bad with item values but I know these are collector items and wanted to check if this was fair.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110460079&userid=403297&signature=Jp-6hYrOOT6NeEVObxv6HQ

I could really use some help. Thanks!

[Animooser]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110594964&userid=329114&signature=CTtI6LN7rmpNYbDGcicHbQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=109821578&userid=329114&signature=iqpe9XSpXQ-U2UGdi3ybrA

Looking for input on two different trades if anyone has time :>

[Audrey_Bee]

I disagree. Looking at trades in the successful trade thread a RR gets 1 non mostly sometimes 1.5 non with those being outliers. The only august pps that trades for 2 nons is the TD's.

8m just speaking from experience from trading for 3 August pps lions, both trading for and trading away and have gotten 2 nons for RR very easily and 2.5 nons for a TD I would not be taking a non dog for one, I personally just think it's very unfair advice !

This is again another conversation about value pushing in this thread. Even if you CAN find someone who's desperate enough to pay a whole 2 nons for it doesn't mean that should be the standard. All the trade data shows it for 1 to 1.5 nons therefore these trades are fair which is what this thread is about it's not a "can I get a better offer?" thread : /

It's not value pushing its my personal experience. The people I have traded have never been desperate, it is just one of those pets, like the raven, that generally gets overpay.
We as people make the values, there's no literal values, any value is based on trade data.
Even if you're saying 1.5 nons, it still makes these trades unfair.
I have a lot more personal experience trading this particular pet recently from the look of it and I'm just giving my honest advice that I would give to anyone:) you can disagree all you want, I was just giving my opinion. Which is what this page is! It's an opinion thread ! ❤️

[SunlightAura]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110595395&userid=34940&signature=jG55DcJYNyUE9CDyK00UQg

[OreozHere]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110595395&userid=34940&signature=jG55DcJYNyUE9CDyK00UQg

i would lean on the side of probably not, your side is a 2014 very rare + 3 new rares, and their side is 1 old rare and 1 new rare. unless your lambs are dupes and you dont mind trading them for common fodder, i wouldnt take it

[See_Air_Ruhh_]

So I've been tentatively looking at offers for my UR Flower Dragon and was curious how these looked?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110548960&userid=115676&signature=uhcxQX7Ci3uDpbRT2tk7qg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110371254&userid=115676&signature=zOMwKlsl687NS_7G0_G8RA

Any input is appreciated.

Any other opinions? Pls and ty ❤️

[SmolDrago]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110595395&userid=34940&signature=jG55DcJYNyUE9CDyK00UQg

Mmm yeah I agree with the person above me, it's probably more unfair to you. New store pets = 1 old rare (I think 2010/2011 is the year used as the benchmark?) So a 2014 VR is probably worth more like 2-3 store pets maybe? Plus the new token pets usually end up as EUC/rare so I'd say they need to add either the C$ equivalent of more store pets (if you prefer C$), or quite a few more recent rares/couple older rares