The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Dawpaw1]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78310825&userid=327768&signature=7EYfoUqcNM_nARCz86HB_g
how’s this?

Unfair to them since there are two ur pets and one advent list while your offering just one ur pet

[Begs]

SOMEONE PLEASE HELP ME I NEED TO KNOW IF THIS IS FAIR FOR PURPLE TOXIC
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78310046&userid=858203&signature=1eFBb0BknneFCUDkI4MCcw looking for 1 more oppinion

[leanlynx]

SOMEONE PLEASE HELP ME I NEED TO KNOW IF THIS IS FAIR FOR PURPLE TOXIC
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78310046&userid=858203&signature=1eFBb0BknneFCUDkI4MCcw

I personally wouldn't accept, demand-wise you can get more for your purple toxic and rarity-wise they are underpaying. Not to mention it's rather hard to trade off tribal dogs as they have such a low demand.

[Targaryen]

Should I accept this? I really want the raven and the marionette but I'm afraid to overpay

Help? I think I'm going to accept

Please? can i get an opinion on this

valuing your side at at least 2 nons and 1 sorb and their side at 1.5 nons roughly, i really wouldn't. (marionette only goes for sorbs really, raven just over a non)

You could maybe hold out and get a 1:1 swap for the cat for the raven, i've seen a few of those trades but it really, really depends on who's trading for them and what they have. It just looks as if you're losing too much value over the head of demand.

@ellybelly2013
62 mid-advent gap between the gearback tribal and the purple toxic. the cake dog is only worth another 6 making the gap roughly 56 mid-advents, or just over 55 depending on how you value the rares they added. They'd need to add roughly just over a Green Toxic and Skeleton PPS for it to be fair.

[zero.two]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78310825&userid=327768&signature=7EYfoUqcNM_nARCz86HB_g
how’s this?

Rarity-wise it's unfair to them

The UR Cucumber alone is overpay by a yellow/green toxic

[madisong]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78310825&userid=327768&signature=7EYfoUqcNM_nARCz86HB_g
how’s this?

Unfair to them since there are two ur pets and one advent list while your offering just one ur pet

I’d say that that’s wrong. The type of pet doesn’t effect its rarity in terms of list placement, if that makes sense.
The cucumber alone is worth more than the Zonkey so that’s why it’s unfair.

[unickorn]

Was this fair? (Ignore the other pets, just pretend it was the zebra


Should I accept?

[Targaryen]

Just got this offer
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78309738&userid=311853&signature=JQcOOIAdVDJqiqbm4QonsA
They are also willing to trade me 2 ur lions for my lion tail set, while should I go for ?

UR Butterfly Wolves struggle to get 1-1.5 nons compared to the Green Liontail alone easily getting 1 non and the two other lions getting at least a sorbet each.

The 2 UR Lions is a much better offer, being worth 2 nons and 1 sorb.

[Relara]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78310388&userid=698931&signature=ZrM1kWnhAQMgKlA7A1D7YA would this be a good trade?

[_Cat~Eye_]

Just got this offer
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78309738&userid=311853&signature=JQcOOIAdVDJqiqbm4QonsA
They are also willing to trade me 2 ur lions for my lion tail set, which should I go for ?