The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ʙʀᴏᴋᴇᴅ™]

Fair? Whos overpaying or underpaying..? What needs to be added? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IOFXMCNdQA

You would be underpaying by a massive amount. The UR cat is worth 2 nons and 2 sorbets. The quantity doesn't even equal 1 sorbet.

Oh ok ty :0

[.:Viv:.]

Hello! Is this fair rarity wise?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hzj6VglfYA
Thank you for any help!

[l y n n x o]

Is THIS trade fair? Would you personally accept it? Thanks in advance!!

[Yammie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64311587&userid=232225&signature=D9kLvQXmR5MAlJcUoFoJqw

I'm really bad at item to pet conversions and i dont remember at all where these items are from, is this fair?

[Silverstar]

Is THIS trade fair? Would you personally accept it? Thanks in advance!!

unfair to you. The aussie is worth a non + sorbet, so no, I wouldn't take it ^^

[ʙʀᴏᴋᴇᴅ™]

Fair? Whos overpaying or underpaying if not? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1FjFRmWz4g

[CaptainSpank]

I came across a Player with the following in their Trade Rules:

RULES:
-Be fair!!!! Do not send unfair trades
Example:
Saying a 2012 very common is overpay for 6 2016 commons, it's not overpay it's not even a fair trade

I pointed out that in my Opinion, a 2012 VC is actually Overpay for 6 2016 Commons:

=> It is actually Overpay, I would think, ah-ah...!:
1x 2012 VC = 1x 2013 Common = 8x 2016 Commons...
And 8x 2016 Commons is Overpay for 6x 2016 Commons, I would think...!?

But they still disagree... Who's right...? Is my "Calculation" not correct...?

[Eagle's Eye]

I came across a Player with the following in their Trade Rules:

RULES:
-Be fair!!!! Do not send unfair trades
Example:
Saying a 2012 very common is overpay for 6 2016 commons, it's not overpay it's not even a fair trade

I pointed out that in my Opinion, a 2012 VC is actually Overpay for 6 2016 Commons:

=> It is actually Overpay, I would think, ah-ah...!:
1x 2012 VC = 1x 2013 Common = 8x 2016 Commons...
And 8x 2016 Commons is Overpay for 6x 2016 Commons, I would think...!?

But they still disagree... Who's right...? Is my "Calculation" not correct...?

Doing rarity math, then yes, a 2012 vc=2014 uncommon=2016 rare=4 2016 uncommonss=8 2016 commons so it'd be overpay on the 2012 side

[Joof]

I came across a Player with the following in their Trade Rules:

RULES:
-Be fair!!!! Do not send unfair trades
Example:
Saying a 2012 very common is overpay for 6 2016 commons, it's not overpay it's not even a fair trade

I pointed out that in my Opinion, a 2012 VC is actually Overpay for 6 2016 Commons:

=> It is actually Overpay, I would think, ah-ah...!:
1x 2012 VC = 1x 2013 Common = 8x 2016 Commons...
And 8x 2016 Commons is Overpay for 6x 2016 Commons, I would think...!?

But they still disagree... Who's right...? Is my "Calculation" not correct...?

I'd have calculated that the same way. Maybe they don't care about dates?
Fair trading is often just players opinions. No set rules. So while one player accepts an older pet of lower rarity another might only trade for same rarity, no matter the date gap (:

[Rookspirit]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SNT_g-Qkiw

Fair? If not, who is underpaying/overpaying?