The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[snowdrake]

They changed it up, is it fair? :3 http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0sHPE39n8w

if I got the re-releases right they now have 6 '09 rares worth of pets on their side, which is fair.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64311491&userid=819890&signature=cEitgv96FEwI9OZ7VeX1YQ
This? Including the demand of the warrior cats

their side is worth 3 '09 rares + a 2010 rare + a '15 rare. I believe you could potentially get more, though, it's not a bad deal.

[Scarlett.]

They changed it up, is it fair? :3 http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0sHPE39n8w

if I got the re-releases right they now have 6 '09 rares worth of pets on their side, which is fair.

I agree, but I feel that you can get slightly more for it, since none of the pets they are
offering have great demand. It depends on how you value the tess horse & the malk pets,
but they aren't the malk dogs/wolves/cats that more people are seeking. I personally wouldn't
accept the trade but it is technically fair c: Also, if you want to trade up onto the list again
using these rares it's relatively harder than trading up with your flop blood dog.

[snowdrake]

They changed it up, is it fair? :3 http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0sHPE39n8w

if I got the re-releases right they now have 6 '09 rares worth of pets on their side, which is fair.

I agree, but I feel that you can get slightly more for it, since none of the pets they
are offering have great demand. It depends on how you value the tess horse & the
malk pets, but they aren't the malk dogs/wolves/cats that more people are seeking.
I personally wouldn't accept the trade but it is technically fair c:

taking into consideration that you can get 6-7 '09 rares for the blood dog as well I'd ask them to add another '09 rare. after all, not many people are willing to trade off list.

[Neptonian]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... c34k6OTH1w

I'm thinking this is unfair to me by almost 200C$. But then again I have no clue about demand of certain pets. So is this at all fair?

[snowdrake]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64311636&userid=450007&signature=Mey6K1Aq1a9Uc34k6OTH1w

I'm thinking this is unfair to me by almost 200C$. But then again I have no clue about demand of certain pets. So is this at all fair?

yes, their side is only worth 285-295 c$.

[Silverstar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64311636&userid=450007&signature=Mey6K1Aq1a9Uc34k6OTH1w

I'm thinking this is unfair to me by almost 200C$. But then again I have no clue about demand of certain pets. So is this at all fair?

yes, their side is only worth 285-295 c$.

I wouldn't overpay that much since their pets don't have high demand. I wouldn't offer more than 325 C$ or so.

[Yammie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lJcUoFoJqw

I'm really bad at item to pet conversions and i dont remember at all where these items are from, is this fair?

[Joof]

They changed it up, is it fair? :3 http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0sHPE39n8w

if I got the re-releases right they now have 6 '09 rares worth of pets on their side, which is fair.

I agree, but I feel that you can get slightly more for it, since none of the pets they are
offering have great demand. It depends on how you value the tess horse & the malk pets,
but they aren't the malk dogs/wolves/cats that more people are seeking. I personally wouldn't
accept the trade but it is technically fair c: Also, if you want to trade up onto the list again
using these rares it's relatively harder than trading up with your flop blood dog.

Uhh, their side only adds up to 5 '09 rares. The 08 tess horse aswell as the turquoise bw had extended release dates until mid '09 and the draft is from aster '10. the store pet is not worth a 09 rare yet. So i counted that up to 5 which makes the trade unfair to you by at least one '09 rare. Rather two as the blood dog has rather good demand (:

[dddddonuts]

would this be fair? i'm not too sure about warrior cat demand

i'm also not too sure about this, as i'm not familiar with items as well

any help would be really appreciated. thanks <3

thank you shadow2204 for the help with the first one, could i get a second opinion about the demand for trade 1?

[Letty]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=64127046&userid=21621&signature=8ngHHbY7DcJ9FCUHGffLww

I know this isn't quite worth the Grinner (I don't think) but should I consider accepting this at all? any thoughts are appreciated, thanks so much in advance! <3