The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[zee99]

What needs to be added to this to be fair?

There needs to be a main list pet added on their side.

Thanks ^^
Of what value? Lower, like a balloon, or higher up?

[GreatWhiteDragon_1]

Fair for target dog?

Unfair to the Target dog

what would make it fair?

mayhaps trying to add in a late '08 pet. The Shima is good, but not good enough to get the Target dog.

[♥Sterek♥]

What needs to be added to this to be fair?

There needs to be a main list pet added on their side.

Thanks ^^
Of what value? Lower, like a balloon, or higher up?

Much higher up, I would say around a Red toxic somewere.

[Morticia]

Thank you to everyone who answered my last question <3
I have a new one though: Is this fair? The owl is a re-release from April 09.
Thank you for any help c:

I would say so. The zodiac dogs have good demand.

Ok, thank you ^^
Second opinion please?

[LastDragonofoldtimes]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KlfWbrvUzg

[♥Sterek♥]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KlfWbrvUzg

Unfair to you. change the pet on your side to a late 10 rare

[galaxy.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24143558&userid=295580&signature=4861iXFNapk6Ifydf2V0sA

Fair? C:

I have no idea how to value just part of the DIY cake set but I'd imagine it's worth quite a bit more than that... you'll probably want another opinion though lol.

for the DIY Cake set, this is the range that is suggested.

Rares List Pet (suggested range is Red Toxic to Balloon Dog)
11 DIY Cake Set - Only ~560 released, very few remain as complete sets

Thank you for your help C: - So what would be fair for a section of it?

Fair? <3

Unfair to the GWJ.

Thanks C: any second opinions?[/quote]

[Ginger Fox]

Is this fair to both of us? what should I change? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0KRTrwxREQ
and I'm just wondering if I should do this. how valuable are the pendants? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... pKrnkyYp3g

[dunsparce]

Hiii. I'm looking to trade a complete set of 08 items consisting of 1 reindeer, 3 pocky, 1 halo, 2 white scarves, 2 green scarves, 3 merry christmas', 3 white socks, 3 green socks, and 4 santa hats.

I went to the item worth thread first, so I could get a rough estimate, but the person who did pointed me here, since I'm looking to get a low list pet for them all and it's a question of fair trading, roundabouts. c:

Together it's:
4x Oct/Nov '08 rare or multiple '09 rares
Low September '08 list pet
10x Late '09 rare
4x Mid '09 rare
3x Mid '09 uncommon

Grinner is worth around 13 mid-late '09 rares, so:
4x Oct/Nov '08 rare or multiple '09 rares
Low September '08 list pet
1 Grinner
1 mid '09 rare
3x mid '09 uncommon

Let's say multiple '09 rares means 3-4 early '09 rares, then it'd be around 12-16 early '09 rares and we'd have another grinner, so:
2 Grinner
Low September '08 list pet
1 mid '09 rare
3x mid '09 uncommon

Now we have low September list pet + mid '09 rare + 3x mid '09 uncommon = fetched grinner.
3x Grinner = 1 Blue Rose.

So Blue Rose, but you can ask someone who knows CS Math better to make sure. (:

tl;dr- So, the question is if a Blue Rose would be a fair trade for them all? c:

[LastDragonofoldtimes]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KlfWbrvUzg

Unfair to you. change the pet on your side to a late 10 rare

Thank you^^