The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Greyfire]

Been a while since I've posted here, but I would love an opinion or two on this trade I just received! Thank you to whoever offers one!

This is the trade!

I know the base worths of the store pet years on both sides of the trade, but I just wanted some opinions on whether or not others would take their offer or if I could could a better offer for my two dogs?

[keayi]

Been a while since I've posted here, but I would love an opinion or two on this trade I just received! Thank you to whoever offers one!

This is the trade!

I know the base worths of the store pet years on both sides of the trade, but I just wanted some opinions on whether or not others would take their offer or if I could could a better offer for my two dogs?

3 '21 Stores = 3 (mid-late) '10 R = 1.5 '09 R

For:
1 '18 Store = 1 '09 R
1 '20 Store = 1 (early) '10 R = 0.5 '09 R

Although the trade is fair, my general advice is older store pets will always be more valuable than newer ones (unless they're insanely popular, such as PPS stores for example). Demand is subjective! These guys don't really have an established demand as far as I can tell, so unless you really want the pets on their side you're probably safer saving your older store dogs!

[NotHereAnymore]

Is this fair? I'm not sure what this rabbit is worth since it's from this year.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105218007&userid=1064234&signature=L4FYbT8bHuDmlc13aTscBA

[keayi]

Is this fair? I'm not sure what this rabbit is worth since it's from this year.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105218007&userid=1064234&signature=L4FYbT8bHuDmlc13aTscBA

Using the 2:1 ratio ...

2 '21 UC = 1 '21 R
1 '21 C = .5 '21 UC = .25 '21 R

For:
1 '23 R = 0.5 '22 R = 0.25 '21 R

They're slightly overpaying~!

[love miccado]

Maybe someone can help me?
I did not play for a long time, and since i came back i only did trades with some new Pets.
so i dont know if this would ne fair.
Thanks for any Help on that.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105218846&userid=342711&signature=jadcl2VosFmyTHX6Pf_nsA

[Summyyyy]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105218440&userid=1007536&signature=_vjBZdwkwznxsfVusPYvOQ

Hi! Was this a fair trade?

[Arctic⚡️Storm]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105217840&userid=119435&signature=ctjdPLxN9dFqqz2XpSWHGQ

Help please? Thanks in advance <3

[SoFancyCake]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105217840&userid=119435&signature=ctjdPLxN9dFqqz2XpSWHGQ

Help please? Thanks in advance <3

I believe I’ve seen the moon swirl going for 2-2.5 [correct if I’m wrong] the joker is 1.5 and the green toxic is .5
In all that’s a 4-4.5 non offer. That’s about what I have seen sunbacks going for. I know the joker has good demand, then toxic and the swirl I’m not too sure about maybe fair to average demand.

[ShiftytheKitty]

is this fair??

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105218330&userid=509952&signature=3ksLEBPNy_zVvhB2W0iG_A

[keayi]

Maybe someone can help me?
I did not play for a long time, and since i came back i only did trades with some new Pets.
so i dont know if this would ne fair.
Thanks for any Help on that.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105218846&userid=342711&signature=jadcl2VosFmyTHX6Pf_nsA

1 '10 R
2 '19 C

For:
2 '11 UC = 1 '10 UC = .5 '10 R
2 '13 R = 1 '12 R = .5 11 R = .25 '10 R

You're slightly under but I want to add the dogs from the Slumber Party event are still pretty popular!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105218440&userid=1007536&signature=_vjBZdwkwznxsfVusPYvOQ

Hi! Was this a fair trade?

1 '19 Store = 1 ''09 R
1 '19 Store = 1 '09 R

For:
The Dec 18th is a rerelease ex-list
Bro Border Collie = 1 MA = 6-9 '09 R

you overpaid ;')

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105217840&userid=119435&signature=ctjdPLxN9dFqqz2XpSWHGQ

Help please? Thanks in advance <3

Moonswirl = 2.5 N
Green Toxic = 0.5 N
Joker = 1.5 N (TD = 2-2.5, a rerelease is worth less, but they're all rereleases in this trade)
Total = ~4.5

For:
Sunback = 4.5 N

I agree it's fair! Depends which pets you like more. The Joker and the Sunback will both always have good demand, so you shouldn't stress about losing one over the other.

is this fair??

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105218330&userid=509952&signature=3ksLEBPNy_zVvhB2W0iG_A

PPS Tiger = 0.5 MA = 3-4 '09 R
PPS Cheetah = 1 MA = 6-9 '09 R

For:
1 '10 R = .5 '09 R
1 '11 R = .5 '10 R = .25 '09 R
1 '13 Store Kistune = 2 MA

You're slightly overpaying because of the Kitsune! But who knows the demand for the PPS stores will only grow...