The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[EchothroughDarkness]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105154805&userid=410864&signature=BO2lFguXwLwYxPFaOqSikw

[Szczur.ki]

Hi!
This trade seems fair to me, but I just wanted a second opinion since I have no preference over the pets and wasn't sure which to keep. Any help is appreciated, thx <3

[Caelus]

Hi!
This trade seems fair to me, but I just wanted a second opinion since I have no preference over the pets and wasn't sure which to keep. Any help is appreciated, thx <3

This would be slightly unfair to you, as the BMD can go for 0.75n while all sorbets other than pink consistently go for 0.5n. They could make up the difference by adding ~1-2 mid advents, but it's not super unfair either way!

[keayi]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105154805&userid=410864&signature=BO2lFguXwLwYxPFaOqSikw

Timberwolf = 2 MA
Hollyfox dog = at least 2 MA
Hollyfox cat = 1 MA
5 MA = ~0.5 NON

Bumblebee/Racecar Spider = 0.25-0.5 N

Pretty fair and they have TDs, so their value will only grow!

[ActualWoodelf]

If anyone wouldn't mind, I could use some help with a trade involving two '09 rare lions on my side and some VR '09 horses/ponies etc. on theirs?

Click!

And if my trading partner sees this, I would like to say thank you for the offer and please don't take offense at my posting here. I am just not good with RRs or with species demand factors. <3

[Kyrova]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105209313&userid=403626&signature=pG1Pa19lHbLzB_wP7bhARg

hello! is this trade fair to the both of us? i'm not entirely sure

[keayi]

If anyone wouldn't mind, I could use some help with a trade involving two '09 rare lions on my side and some VR '09 horses/ponies etc. on theirs?

Click!

And if my trading partner sees this, I would like to say thank you for the offer and please don't take offense at my posting here. I am just not good with RRs or with species demand factors. <3

Single-Colored RBM = reg '09 VR = 2 '09 R
2 reg '09 VR ponies = 4 '09 R
Bwolf = 1 '09 R

For:
2 '09 R lions

They would be overpaying by 5 '09 R. Lions obviously have much better demand than horses and ponies, but that's entirely opinion-based and only up for you to decide! Their side being entirely made up of RR is also upto you. Some people care about rerelease and values pets as such, others do not.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105209313&userid=403626&signature=pG1Pa19lHbLzB_wP7bhARg

hello! is this trade fair to the both of us? i'm not entirely sure

Moonswirl bun = 1 MA due to poor demand
'08 R =1-2 '09 R

For:
2014 Store = 0.5 MA

Technically they're overpaying by like .75 MA.

[very_tiny_birb]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105192215&userid=37222&signature=GUdjDJMFhMx0yky3T7tG6g
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105196938&userid=37222&signature=bGVRdz9Brp7BBum7O7v6Bw

What do you think of these trades? The first is the original and the second is my counter offer. I'm trying to learn as much as I can about trading so I want to make sure I'm fair in the future ^^ TY!

[Yunjin]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105192215&userid=37222&signature=GUdjDJMFhMx0yky3T7tG6g
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105196938&userid=37222&signature=bGVRdz9Brp7BBum7O7v6Bw

What do you think of these trades? The first is the original and the second is my counter offer. I'm trying to learn as much as I can about trading so I want to make sure I'm fair in the future ^^ TY!

The second offer was fair, the first trade was under. The recent commons aren't enough to cover the gap of a 2012 uncommon.

[very_tiny_birb]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105192215&userid=37222&signature=GUdjDJMFhMx0yky3T7tG6g
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105196938&userid=37222&signature=bGVRdz9Brp7BBum7O7v6Bw

What do you think of these trades? The first is the original and the second is my counter offer. I'm trying to learn as much as I can about trading so I want to make sure I'm fair in the future ^^ TY!

The second offer was fair, the first trade was under. The recent commons aren't enough to cover the gap of a 2012 uncommon.

Thank you! I felt bad once they responded because I didn't know if I was accidentally overcharging them or not, but I was pretty sure that was how the 2:1 rule worked.