The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ROX.mp4]

ive been staring at this offer for ages im kinda in shock, do I take this..?? are people really offering this much for tokens or is this like a one off offer I cant take for granted?/lh

[*Hollystar*]

ive been staring at this offer for ages im kinda in shock, do I take this..?? are people really offering this much for tokens or is this like a one off offer I cant take for granted?/lh

Personally I can not think of any way this would be fair. The number of pets you would get- even if they ended up rare- would still not be worth the pets in this trade. And tokens are just items if not used. I think this is a one off offer I can't imagine more people are willing to pay so highly for current event pets.

[Inactive.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110537450&userid=413523&signature=sh7uZU_sIxYwCiVNW-1teA

Is this fair? I'm terrible with item rarity although I'm leaning no?

Not fair, those items are wayy underpay

The medieval fare masks go for a 2010-2011 rare alone

[Harley_Quinn21]

Hey yall, just needing some help with this as I have no clue when it comes to high value pets/items
Thank you in advance for any opinions!!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110539110&userid=675673&signature=4rTivZ29HO5F-LfA8FJqsA

PS if you’re the other person in this trade I’m gonna be logging off here in a few and I’ll respond tmr for sure, it’s just almost 5 AM my time and I forgot sleeping is a thing lol

[Not Megavolt]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110539106&userid=1105278&signature=7MvHgS_L6qhh1mQETFYSLg

i'm really iffy on this one but they say its overtrade im like ? need help!

[Nokomis_Nitir]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110539106&userid=1105278&signature=7MvHgS_L6qhh1mQETFYSLg

i'm really iffy on this one but they say its overtrade im like ? need help!

Their VR Butterfly Wolf is from 09. It's a Dec 18th RR
archive/2009/November/Butterfly%20wolf

Your pets are from 10' and newer so yes they would be over paying and you would need to add some to make if fair. If they sent it they probably already know they are over paying [from the sounds of it] and are doing so on purpose. Please feel free to get a second opinion but this is just from looking at the surface.

Items are valued generally as a UC of their release year.

[Foxx.ie]

With 0.75nons added to my side, how would this trade look. Im a bit hesitant to trade the joker dog away as i really do like it, but the UR pastel dog is one of my dream pets too. Which side would i be better off with considering both value and demand?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110539519&userid=950038&signature=V9zBCKs2BHz_PK2V226_ag

[Mewy Da Mewy]

Just received this trade and am unsure of the fairness! Which one was better in terms of rarity and demand? And also in the longer run!

<3

[Audrey_Bee]

Just received this trade and am unsure of the fairness! Which one was better in terms of rarity and demand? And also in the longer run!

<3

I personally would keep your pets as the sunjewel doesn't have amazing demand ❤️ there's also a lot of high demand pets on your side with it being predominantly store pets

[ACat]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110540019&userid=85238&signature=aJEN8ThY2bmAIh-Ju3tE-Q

Does this look okay for these token pets? (they're doubles)