The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Llazybonezz]

is this fair?i feel like it is but i’d love a second opinion

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105200049&userid=631866&signature=KlYk0vtrIlUESGVnqEn_ug

[keayi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105200058&userid=983838&signature=iMM_ekUKTGKmZU9yQrG5iw

would this be fair for me and my trading partner?

3 '23 R = 1.5 '22 R = .75 '21 R. = .375 '20 R = .75 '20 UC = 1.5 '20 C
2 '23 C = 1 '22 C = .5 '21 C = .25 '20 C
1 '22 UC = .5 '21 UC = .25 '20 UC = .5 '20 C
Total =. 2.25 '20 C

For:
1 '19 UC
3 '20 C
3 '20 UC

Technically, they are underpaying you but most people don't really use technical values in year differences to deal with commons/uncommons, so it's upto you if you want to accept or edit.

is this fair?i feel like it is but i’d love a second opinion :)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105200049&userid=631866&signature=KlYk0vtrIlUESGVnqEn_ug

1 '11 UC
1 '12 UC = .5 '11 UC
1 '15 UC
1 '17 R

For:
Cake Slice 4 = 2009 CS Birthday = 1 '09 R
5 Cakes = 2010 CS Birthday = 5 '10 UC/R
Horse blankets = 2011 CS Birthday = 2 '11 UC/R

Couldn't find the pillows, but I wouldn't take this because your items are worth more than the pets offered due to being released much sooner than their pets.

[Underworld]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105194306&userid=15405&signature=HxsGf9PucHiHBL_g4aYtcg

Is this fair? Taking out the re-release 09 dog and it’s for one of the sets dachshund or deer.

[mymelody<3]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105202248&userid=1064257&signature=yN_f_Kuct5aUPwfgYC4Gxw
Hi! Is this fair? Tysm to any help!♡

[river blossom]

I am so bad with lists LOL

Yellow Toxic = 0.5 N and usually trades as such
Gray Mini Husky = 1 MA

Red X PPS = 0.25 N
Santa Hat Dog = 1 MA
Floppy Blood Dog = 1 MA
Purple Star Bobtail = 1 MA
'12 Store = 1 MA

4 MA = 0.25 N (+ 0.25 = 0.5 N total on their side)

their side is fair for just the yellow toxic, however the added 1 MA on your side is making you overpay.

that's what I thought thank you !

[Juliamon]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105202248&userid=1064257&signature=yN_f_Kuct5aUPwfgYC4Gxw
Hi! Is this fair? Tysm to any help!♡

This feels pretty fair to me! The sloth store pet is worth a late '09 rare, so while the early '10 rare is a little less than that I think the bulk (plus the C$) makes up for it.

[mymelody<3]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105202248&userid=1064257&signature=yN_f_Kuct5aUPwfgYC4Gxw
Hi! Is this fair? Tysm to any help!♡

This feels pretty fair to me! The sloth store pet is worth a late '09 rare, so while the early '10 rare is a little less than that I think the bulk (plus the C$) makes up for it.

Thank you!

[致你 ౨ৎ]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105196541&userid=780015&signature=8iraONCyl6D_YksOxCTmEg how much c$ is worth?

[dionaea]

could i get some advice on fairness and demand and such? thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105204878&userid=204354&signature=IcGIL-UBi-V2NMVE0Wjeww

edit: this as well please!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105204915&userid=204354&signature=4ZLL9ji6MOOwmeBHLGXqnA

[keayi]

could i get some advice on fairness and demand and such? thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105204878&userid=204354&signature=IcGIL-UBi-V2NMVE0Wjeww

edit: this as well please!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105204915&userid=204354&signature=4ZLL9ji6MOOwmeBHLGXqnA

1)
2009 Orange Colours Dog = Regular 2009 VR (2 '09 R)
2009 Light pink shima bwolf = Regular 2009 VR (2 '09 R)
2009 Yellow poisondart bwolf = .5-.75 MA (3-6 '09 R)
2009 Springbok bwolf = .5-.75 MA (3-6 '09 R)
Total = 10-16 '09 R

For:
2009 Green-Nosed Rainbow Leopard = .5-.75 MA (3-6 '09 R)
2009 White Rainbow Leopard = Regular 2009 VR (2 '09 R)
2009 Watermelon Dog = 1 MA (6-9 '09 R)
Total = 11-17 '09 R

None of them have any special demand if I can recall and probably all trade for their base values (in fact I would not guarantee any will trade for more than 0.5 MA (besides the watermelon dog = 1 MA)). They all kind of fall in the same value-range so it's upto you if you prefer a higher quantity or just like one side more than the other.


2)
2018 Store Set = 1 '09 R/ea = 4 '09 R

For:
Striped valentines PPS = .5-.75 MA (3-6 '09 R)
2008 Mismatch Green Oct = 0.5 MA (3-4 '09 R)
2009 Watermelon Dog = 1 MA (6-9 '09 R)

I wouldn't take it because I don't think those stores have good demand. I forgot they even existed ^^""