The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sky,]

So, I know that two 2015 rares don't go for this much on the regular, but I am asking about demand. I regularly see the dragons going for more than they are worth rarity wise. Is this fair? To me it seems like too much but the other user was asking for more for them (.5 MA for the green one) I just want to make sure I am not jipping them out. Or myself out haha. Thank you to anyone who helps me out!


trade

[bubblegumjello]

i am horrible with item value but these should all be from around 2016/17

for reference: theres 83 items and 21 pets

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105184455&userid=672037&signature=yBdAfIAXUpvjbyk1gzXiPw

[keayi]

So, I know that two 2015 rares don't go for this much on the regular, but I am asking about demand. I regularly see the dragons going for more than they are worth rarity wise. Is this fair? To me it seems like too much but the other user was asking for more for them (.5 MA for the green one) I just want to make sure I am not jipping them out. Or myself out haha. Thank you to anyone who helps me out!


trade

I recently traded a '20 store pet for the TD PPS dragon, so I basically paid 35-40 C$ / 1 '10 R for it, so the demand isn't too far off... still, 60 C$/ea feels pretty steep. I also traded for those same pets just last year, and didn't have to trade more than a year out of their OG value (black GUPPS, green PPS)
I know me saying this doesn't really help, but it all comes down to you! I personally think it's too much (and asking 0.5 MA is... ridiculous). If you want to take it, know the value of these pets is only going to grow as time goes on! Buuuut there's still a chance someone will trade you fairer in the near future.

Also, didn't know they were part of the Dec 18th rerelease group lol.

i am horrible with item value but these should all be from around 2016/17

for reference: theres 83 items and 21 pets

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105184455&userid=672037&signature=yBdAfIAXUpvjbyk1gzXiPw

In general, items are worth an uncommon from the same year they are released. This tends to fluctuate up/down in rarity based on its usability, likeability, quantity, etc,etc.

Based on this alone, I think it's safe to say you're overpaying. By a lot. You basically have 83 2016-2017 UC, while they only have 22 pets from just last year and this year. As a guide, pets are only worth half as much as a pet of the same rarity released in the previous year (ex: '22 UC = 0.5 '21 UC = .25 '20 UC = .125 '19 UC = 0.06 '18 UC = 0.03 '17 UC)
If it were me and I just wanted to make it easy, I'd trade 10.5-21 items for 21 pets.

[CristalStar]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105186212&userid=983838&signature=zK4UYPrHz9KiO7bFbPfPiw

[CristalStar]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105186242&userid=983838&signature=VOq1ErJq6reU4Yvk0YH86g

not sure if this is fair to my tading partner or not but would like to see if or how I could make this fair if it is not thank you

[Sp3ctra1]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105187447&userid=856988&signature=mll_AMIKfmg5znrWzdYjuA

Not very good at item worth, is this a fair trade? Thank you in advance <3

[Sp3ctra1]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105186242&userid=983838&signature=VOq1ErJq6reU4Yvk0YH86g

not sure if this is fair to my tading partner or not but would like to see if or how I could make this fair if it is not thank you

Im pretty sure all warrior cats are worth .5 MA each, so the full trade should equal 1 MA, pretty sure your side is very under since a .5 ma is worth like maybe 1-4 09 rares, would wait for another opinion to suggest something tho

[matthew patel]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105188301&userid=1074987&signature=2pdiQ9j12JITEb0qn7nmEw
would this be a fair trade? i have no idea how to value store pets

[teariffic]

thoughts?

[alicewins]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105189050&userid=767773&signature=wVj2ED_EYPhAk0LYECfzEA

I’m struggling with the dates - is this fair to me? ^^