The “Is this a fair trade?” Thread

[TzatzikiTheLeg]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70122237&userid=656649&signature=eokGkMteM_3Q3ZiAdZefPA

Would this be fair?

Could I get at least two opinions?

The BW is the 4th highest list pet, so this definitely isn't fair rarity wise.Demand wise,still unfair to you.

[pigeon -]

running an auction for off-list and wondered which would be the fairest? thanks!
one ; two

The second is worth a little over 4 mid advents which is overpay for the scarf PPS, but the first one is a broken link uwu

thanks c:
fixed it ;;

[Constellation.]

Back again! The third trade added and now I'm stuck.

WARNING: LARGE QUANTITY (of rares) IN THESE

Trade one
Trade two + This + This

They added more rares and lists. Again considering all pets will be sold for C$ (but the lists will be traded down and then sold for C$), which one is best? (:

Thanks! (: Second opinion? Added again.

[Horsefreak]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... qT9x92eZVg

Rarity wise, very unfair to the rats. However, considering demand, I would say it's fair. Demand is a user based thing however, so everyone will have different opinions.

[Trickz]

Red Toxic = Blue Balloon + Pink Balloon

Is this fair, or does someone need to add?

At least one more opinion please c:

[Constellation.]

Back again! The third trade added and now I'm stuck.

WARNING: LARGE QUANTITY (of rares) IN THESE

Trade one
Trade two + This + This

They added more rares and lists. Again considering all pets will be sold for C$ (but the lists will be traded down and then sold for C$), which one is best? (:

Thanks! (: Second opinion? Added again.

[pigeon -]

running an auction for off-list and wondered which would be the fairest? thanks!
one ; two

had one response, would love some more ;;

[Coleslaw]

running an auction for off-list and wondered which would be the fairest? thanks!
one ; two

The first is around the same value, a little over four mid advents. At that point it’s up to you which pets you prefer~

[karachi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70121349&userid=795826&signature=pEHDibeqCIQB6TOmCYLd8w

Is that fair?

[GhostPants]

How does this trade look (:
@Gasoline
EDIT: How does this one look?
(Thanks for those who answer(ed)!