The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[Unforgiven~]

hello! may i have a few opinions?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VhCeFOKpzA

is it worth the trade up demand and rarity wise, or could i get something higher for it, say a Growing White July? If i could get a GWJ, what would I need to add to my side to make it fair for it?
~Wolfie

I am not an EXPERT at this stuff but that seems fair because of the years, if you made them the same year (taking off from rarity to do the years) it would be about the same I think...

[Mother Of Dragons’]

1~HarryPotter<3 gave this ~
2~D.GraymanFan gave this~
3~Sakura Kyoko gave this ~
4~squidink gave this ~
5~FloridaGeorgiaLine gave this ~ between and

These are the second round people in my auction, I already eliminated one but I don't know who else to eliminate. These are all links to the trades and I am SO stuck on even one or two more to eliminate. They are all AWESOME offers for the 2008 (re-released in 2010) brown cookie dog (he is on the advent rare list) can anyone help me?

First and second both unfair to you...third and fifth more fair...I think the fifth one is best...

[Mother Of Dragons’]

hello! may i have a few opinions?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VhCeFOKpzA

is it worth the trade up demand and rarity wise, or could i get something higher for it, say a Growing White July? If i could get a GWJ, what would I need to add to my side to make it fair for it?
~Wolfie

I am not an EXPERT at this stuff but that seems fair because of the years, if you made them the same year (taking off from rarity to do the years) it would be about the same I think...

Please do not answer if you don't know your stuff...technically its unfair to the CE because demand for the Tess horse sucks, I would recommend seeing if you can get something better...

[Unforgiven~]

I already eliminated the 5th one because I just can't choose, they are all awesome bids to me

1~HarryPotter<3 gave this ~
2~D.GraymanFan gave this~
3~Sakura Kyoko gave this ~
4~squidink gave this ~
5~FloridaGeorgiaLine gave this ~ between and

These are the second round people in my auction, I already eliminated one but I don't know who else to eliminate. These are all links to the trades and I am SO stuck on even one or two more to eliminate. They are all AWESOME offers for the 2008 (re-released in 2010) brown cookie dog (he is on the advent rare list) can anyone help me?

First and second both unfair to you...third and fifth more fair...I think the fifth one is best...

[Schofield]

hello! may i have a few opinions?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VhCeFOKpzA

is it worth the trade up demand and rarity wise, or could i get something higher for it, say a Growing White July? If i could get a GWJ, what would I need to add to my side to make it fair for it?
~Wolfie

I am not an EXPERT at this stuff but that seems fair because of the years, if you made them the same year (taking off from rarity to do the years) it would be about the same I think...

Please do not answer if you don't know your stuff...technically its unfair to the CE because demand for the Tess horse sucks, I would recommend seeing if you can get something better...

It would take almost another CE Galaxy to get up to the same level of Rares List.
Yes the Tess Horse demand is bad, but I think this is overpay. :C

[siilence]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... p25a6rfEAw
What needs to be added to this to make it fair? c:

I'm on the other side, so I'd like to know too. Thanks

[Schofield]

What needs to be added to this to be fair?

There needs to be a main list pet added on their side.

[Unforgiven~]

1~HarryPotter<3 gave this ~
2~D.GraymanFan gave this~
3~Sakura Kyoko gave this ~
4~squidink gave this ~
5~FloridaGeorgiaLine gave this ~ between and

These are the second round people in my auction, I already eliminated one but I don't know who else to eliminate. These are all links to the trades and I am SO stuck on even one or two more to eliminate. They are all AWESOME offers for the 2008 (re-released in 2010) brown cookie dog (he is on the advent rare list) can anyone help me?

May I have a second opinion?

[Furry Luva]

What more should I add to my side to make this fair if it is unfair to them?

Their Edited Response:

This was their edited response. Is it fair? =/ I really must know....

[lame]

all pets in this group = ?

sorry if this doesn't belong here, i don't really know where to ask this ouo