The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[Duvessa]

Fair? Anyone know? =]
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eUrTJXdGWA

[Shadow2204]

I really need help with this http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hrsU-phxmQ is it fair?

The rose dog have a 67% (2/3) chance of becoming one of the two rose dogs (red rose or blue rose) from the september list and a 33% (1/3) chance of becoming the rose pps on the main list.
So you have a 33% chance of it becoming somewhat fair. I personally wouldn't take it because I wouldn't want to take a gamble, especially if the chances are in the favor of them.

Taking this into account what should they add?

Say the rose dog grows into the red rose, which is worth the least out of the litter. The red rose is worth 5 mid advents and the grey dragon is worth 8 mid advents. They would need to add the worth of a scarf pps or 3 mid advents. That's just rarity wise.

[softpaw]

i don't know how much the red cerberus goes for these days, is this fair?

[carnivorous.]

@melanie martinez
Thank you, could I get another opinion?
In your own opinion, would you accept this trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SR6vz3XUAg
The growing pet is a UR B-wolf ^^

I most certainly would, that’s literally the best trade i’ve seen for the peas
Although the UR B-wolf has a little unsatisfactory demand, this to me is extreme overpay because of the rarity of the butterfly wolf, and it’s placement on the list.

[The Plague.]

O k is this good?

[♥Emerald♥]

i don't know how much the red cerberus goes for these days, is this fair?

The UR tiger dog is equal to the sunjewel which both of them are VERY valuable. The red Cerberus is on the September list so that doesn’t really add up. The two UR donkeys still don’t help it add up to the UR tiger dog making this unfair to you.

[chiamai]

looking for any & all opinions. about how many nons does the sunjewel go for & how many nons is my side approx


ALSO, Is this fair/ what needs to be added.

UR Cat VS UR bee + Drink Me

I appreciate any help for either !!

[Fishrabies]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... zNsQtTxIhQ
Help me , is this fair, or i there any way I can make this fair

[♥Emerald♥]

looking for any & all opinions. about how many nons does the sunjewel go for & how many nons is my side approx


ALSO, Is this fair/ what needs to be added.

UR Cat VS UR bee + Drink Me

I appreciate any help for either !!

I think you may want to add another main list, then, depending on which main list you add, the trade will hopefully be equal to the demand of the sunjewel.

[Shadow2204]

all of these are bids for the whole zodiac dog set.

trade 1

trade 2

trade 3

trade 4

trade 5

trade 6

trade 7

trade 8

could someone tell me the order of rarity from greatest to least? thank you!

please note that i am looking for c$ so don't tell me that a trade is bad just because it is mainly c$.

Zodiac set is worth a low september, in C$, they are worth 300-360C$ rarity wise.

1. Well, the cupid arrow + cupid bow would be worth a early '09 rare together, so i'm unsure about what it's worth alone. But that's the only valuable item i see. So they're offering around 9 '09 rares which is worth a high advent.
2. Winged blood dog is a mid september by itself so that is overpay. Their cat plushie item is worth a '09 rare by rarity.
3. 200C$ is worth a mid september (pink striped sept.) + they're offering 12 '09 rares of worth.
4. 90C$ is worth a teal butterbun (high advent) + 3 '09 rares worth of store pets.
5. 400C$ is overpaying by 40C$ by rarity worth of the zodiac set. The 2 '09 rares are bonuses.
6. Two tier 8 advents = 14-16 '09 rares + a '10 rare (around the worth of a low september). Though, they have low demand.
7. 66C$ os worth a peppermint bun (low advent). BMD bun is a mid advent & they're offering 6 '09 rares + a '10 rare.
8. Grinner is a low september. 2 '09 rares + a '10 rare + items are bonuses.

Based on overpay & because you're looking for C$: 5, 3, 2, 8, 6, 4, 7, 1