The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice 2nd post]

[Jaskiest]

You only need to have 1 of the rares in there

Erh, ok I'm pretty sure that's not right either though. ^^; The shima's are quite sought after, last I checked.
Thank you though.
Could I maybe get a second opinion?

The Shima does have good demand, but you are still overpaying.

[&& echo;]

Is this fair?
xXx
Thank you in advance to anyone who helps. c:

Fair if you look dates, Not if you look demand.

You only need to have 1 of the rares in there

Summer don't give false information. Shima Long Tail is in huge demand is beond this, she goes Adven't list pet's easely.

hey, you shouldn't be saying that correct advice is incorrect, and giving VERY incorrect advice in return.
the trade is VERY unfair to wild pariah. only ONE of the rares is needed- maybe two, if trying to cover demand. ^^;

[Valantherial]

Is this fair?
xXx
Thank you in advance to anyone who helps. c:

Fair if you look dates, Not if you look demand.

You only need to have 1 of the rares in there

Summer don't give false information. Shima Long Tail is in huge demand is beond this, she goes Adven't list pet's easely.

hey, you shouldn't be saying that correct advice is incorrect, and giving VERY incorrect advice in return.
the trade is VERY unfair to wild pariah. only ONE of the rares is needed- maybe two, if trying to cover demand. ^^;

I disagree. The Shima Longtail has a wildly high demmand, and thus is actually worth far more than it first appears. It all depends on whether it is an auction or not- and upon how much each player values it. Auctionwise, this would probably not be a winning bid- though it could be close-ish. I would say that whilst demmand unfoots it, and makes pricing fluid- 1 or 2 '09 Rares would not be of equivalent value. If it's a bid, keep it like that until the end, and if it is a trade- I would say... See what the other player says. Some players may trade for that, others value the Longtail higher. Of course- this is just my opinion, so not concrete. Good luck!~

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YIzdX1uMyA

Is that fair, or unfair? If unfair- to whom?
Thanks,
Vala~

[Edwawd]

Fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u4ctc2-8Ng

[♥Sterek♥]

Fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u4ctc2-8Ng

Looks okay to me, with the 3 moth a bit unfair to them probably

[Queen Vivane]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HP4DdEY5FA
I'm horrible with rarities and so rusty at trading. So could someone give me some advice please? ^^;;

[Yoyce]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26834641&userid=33217&signature=UolvacHrjcAkHP4DdEY5FA
I'm horrible with rarities and so rusty at trading. So could someone give me some advice please? ^^;;

I don't think the unipegs are really worth that much

[Wolvefine]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... J-zA1rHq0A

I have no plan of the worth of items -.-
Fair?

[nymphadora.]

Im pretty sure this is really unfair to me..but could someone check?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... H5XKyCHQyA

[♥Sterek♥]

Im pretty sure this is really unfair to me..but could someone check?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... H5XKyCHQyA

Unfair to them a mid advent is worth 7 '09 rares