The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[spacecatmint]

I am auctioning off my Target dog and I'm pretty sure this is fair but I just want second opinions :). Should I auto this?
Trade

the target dog is 2 mid advents + 2 '09 rares (14-18 09 rares) and their side is worth 12-14 09 rares. if you value the zodiacs at an 09 rare each, their side is worth 13-15 09 rares c:

[sluiceway]

What's the current demand like on Malk dragons right now?
Are they really worth advents? I've been super inactive so I have no idea what demand is right now but I don't want it to be unfair to them

edit;;
also which is a better offer on my '08 UR Cat: a Coontail or a Red Cerb +?
also how is this?

The first one is overpay. The Dragon isn't a list, so it's technically worth the three month rule, but some people overpay. And they offered a tier 3 or 4 advent list.

The second one I saw unfair to them because they pineapple is worth 2 sorbets and the ur apple, but usual Goes for less.

Second opinion? And how's the offers on my UR Cat?

[SimplySinister]

Grinner + grinner = ?

[darkbay]

Do two 2010 uncommon equal a 2016 rare?

[sluiceway]

Do two 2010 uncommon equal a 2016 rare?

A '14 uncommon = '16 rare
But it also depends on species, demand, etc.

[spacecatmint]

Grinner + grinner = ?

about a pink striped september c:

Do two 2010 uncommon equal a 2016 rare?

(valuing a rare at 4 uncommons)

two 2010 uncommons are worth a 2011 rare.
two 2015 uncommons or one 2014 uncommon is worth a 2016 rare

one 2014 uncommon = two 2015 uncommons = four 2016 uncommons = 2016 rare

[Letty]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63423074&userid=21621&signature=-jCdekzTastEc8Gm3JOcSw

Is this alright for my Warrior? I usually don't trade these guys away so I'm a little rusty on the gap between their demand and value. ^^ Thanks in advance! <3

[.crossfire.]

Fair?? I've been asking for many pages

[Letty]

Fair?? I've been asking for many pages

Ahh, I know that feeling, I'm so sorry you had to wait this long. :c From what I can see this is VERY unfair to you; your tribal is a Mainlist and they are offering mainly a September list and a very low advent which just plain doesn't add up to your side. ^^

[Mothsu]

Fair?
Thank you in advance!