The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Hauntednightmares]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63486894&userid=867096&signature=XPz2Jq2OA0zxMXbckzQ_2g

is this fair? what must be added or taken away

I'd say it's just barely unfair. The BMD has a pretty high demand along with the Cerberus, so just the two would be fair I believe. The cerb is about a non and The bee is two or three tiers above the nons so I'd imagine the BMD covers it? Get another opinion

Well my bee is worth 2 nons, so if ceb is a non, would balloon and bmd make up for the other non that is needed?

[pigeon -]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63486894&userid=867096&signature=XPz2Jq2OA0zxMXbckzQ_2g

is this fair? what must be added or taken away

I'd say it's just barely unfair. The BMD has a pretty high demand along with the Cerberus, so just the two would be fair I believe. The cerb is about a non and The bee is two or three tiers above the nons so I'd imagine the BMD covers it? Get another opinion

as far as I know, the bee is worth 2 nons and the red cerb goes for around 1 non,
the bmd is consistently going for a balloon dog tier, however the balloon dog and
the bmd wouldn't add up to another non so going by that it's unfair to you c:

[Fwutter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63486894&userid=867096&signature=XPz2Jq2OA0zxMXbckzQ_2g

is this fair? what must be added or taken away

I'd say it's just barely unfair. The BMD has a pretty high demand along with the Cerberus, so just the two would be fair I believe. The cerb is about a non and The bee is two or three tiers above the nons so I'd imagine the BMD covers it? Get another opinion

I'll have to disagree on that one. The UR bee is worth 2 nons. The most the BMD goes for is a balloon dog, the Cerberus is going for a non at most and the BMD is definitely not worth a non it's self. The balloon dog + BMD is not worth a non demand or rarity wise. So it's unfair to your UR bee.

[.crossfire.]

What's the current demand like on Malk dragons right now?
Are they really worth advents? I've been super inactive so I have no idea what demand is right now but I don't want it to be unfair to them

edit;;
also which is a better offer on my '08 UR Cat: a Coontail or a Red Cerb +?
also how is this?

The first one is overpay. The Dragon isn't a list, so it's technically worth the three month rule, but some people overpay. And they offered a tier 3 or 4 advent list.

The second one I saw unfair to them because they pineapple is worth 2 sorbets and the ur apple, but usual Goes for less.

Fair?? I've been asking for many pages

[sleepyhead.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63487622&userid=798243&signature=muKVvsb9OSllhtZkqof68g
Not so great with item trades,
Is this fair to me?
(Im the side with items.)

[Fwutter]

I am auctioning off my Target dog and I'm pretty sure this is fair but I just want second opinions :). Should I auto this?
Trade

[Odasakn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63487705&userid=797289&signature=c3JNQyvde_lcnzibOtvICw

Would I have to add and if so what should I add???

[Silphy]

Is this fair?

[.crossfire.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63487705&userid=797289&signature=c3JNQyvde_lcnzibOtvICw

Would I have to add and if so what should I add???

It's fair, but yet overpay. The dog they want is within three months of the zodiac, but a zodiacs demand makes it go for about an '09 rare

[Fwutter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63487705&userid=797289&signature=c3JNQyvde_lcnzibOtvICw

Would I have to add and if so what should I add???

Nothing! This is a fair swap within the 3 month rule :>. But if your talking about about demand you would have to add another '10 rare.