The “Is this a fair trade?” thread

[Corey Taylor]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _Je9T7oktA

How fair is this?

[GhostPants]

How are these trades?
[1. XXX]
[2. XXX]
[3. XXX]
@Gasoline [Note] Thank you for anyone who answers!

[LeaLooHoo]

Hey OstrichKitty51 i think #2 is the best!

[Black Clover]

my ur flower auction ended and i was wondering if i should accept any of these trades or if i should see if i can tweek some
1-Not the biggest fan of rats but nice
2-i like the offer but i dunno man XD
3-like the gear back
4-i love the apple and old pets along with the C$ amount!

[GhostPants]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71019883&userid=781126&signature=Mpc8JP6Q6Uu3_Je9T7oktA

How fair is this?

Unfair. The zebra goes for 1570.
They would need to add 430 to make it fair.

[GhostPants]

my ur flower auction ended and i was wondering if i should accept any of these trades or if i should see if i can tweek some
1-Not the biggest fan of rats but nice
2-i like the offer but i dunno man XD
3-like the gear back
4-i love the apple and old pets along with the C$ amount!

None of them are that fair...
The UR flower goes for 2 sorbets & a green toxic, and so far none of these add up to that value...
But get a second opinion.

[Black Clover]

my ur flower auction ended and i was wondering if i should accept any of these trades or if i should see if i can tweek some
1-Not the biggest fan of rats but nice
2-i like the offer but i dunno man XD
3-like the gear back
4-i love the apple and old pets along with the C$ amount!

None of them are that fair...
The UR flower goes for 2 sorbets & a green toxic, and so far none of these add up to that value...
But get a second opinion.

yes i know but which one is better and coud use the least amount of tweeking?

[GhostPants]

[-big ol snip-]
None of them are that fair...
The UR flower goes for 2 sorbets & a green toxic, and so far none of these add up to that value...
But get a second opinion.

yes i know but which one is better and coud use the least amount of tweeking?

well.
1) UR Rat has terrible demand, which is why its a GAP mainlist... to make it fair you have to add roughly a sorbet + red x tier (?)
2) EXTREMELY unfair. none of those pets are list and thats not enough c$. To make it fair 2 sorbs + roughly green tox tier would need to be added.
3) also unfair, the whole tribal set have terrible demand. 2 sorbs would need to be added. even with all the old items.. [most]
4) also VERy unfair. the apple has terrible demand. 2 sorbs + [roughly] line tribal tier would need to be added.

Im not an expert so most of these might still be unfair, even with the pets added, their educated guesses.
Hope this helped

[Black Clover]

i got another offer i know these are decent pets, need opinions please help?

[atreyu]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=71024341&userid=656649&signature=CSnZE2yzM7Dxo9MD8JVN7Q

Is this fair?