The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Joof]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63485281&userid=573067&signature=_9yfb9uciSNgZYCMCEjF7A

This fair? I'm REALLY tempted to accept it!

Honestly I would accept that. I gave someone an UR white malk for my lolita, and the light leopard isn't easy to trade away either. Honestly I've seen the lolita go for more.

Well, rarity wise unfair to you by a mid advent and a 09 rare. I'm not sure about lolita demand, it goes for overpay though, but a white malk dragon would be way overpay. And just because you paid that for a lolita, doesn't mean that's what it usually goes for (:

[.crossfire.]

Would this trade be fair, over, or under? If it's under, what do I need to add?
Trade 1) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4fcD5rLCrw

And would this trade be fair? (same deal, is it fair over or under? If it's under, what do I need to add?)
Trade 2) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YL882ofeZQ

It's an over pay. They basically just need the horse.

[watery>~<]

i'd really like some help with some bids on my auction as i'm stumped;
one has items which they said were valuable but i don't know how valuable aha

• one
• two
• three

thank you! c:

Personally I'd go with number two. It has a high advent list. Trade one does too, but it has a lot of items, and trade two has a Zodiac dog which can easily grab an '09 rare or two

If you are looking for 2nd opinions I would agree with what ToothyToothless said. Zodiac dogs are really easy to trade off and can go for way higher than it's actual worth. I'm not that good with items so I would still suggest you get another opinion. If most of those items are from 2009 and are not store bought, then I think I might choose the first one.

[Fwutter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63485281&userid=573067&signature=_9yfb9uciSNgZYCMCEjF7A

This fair? I'm REALLY tempted to accept it!

Honestly I would accept that. I gave someone an UR white malk for my lolita, and the light leopard isn't easy to trade away either. Honestly I've seen the lolita go for more.

Well, rarity wise unfair to you by a mid advent and a 09 rare. I'm not sure about lolita demand, it goes for overpay though, but a white malk dragon would be way overpay. And just because you paid that for a lolita, doesn't mean that's what it usually goes for (:

^^^ Thing Is i traded about 5-6 people the white malk and they all declined before I got an accepted trade for it.

[Joof]

Would this trade be fair, over, or under? If it's under, what do I need to add?
Trade 1) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4fcD5rLCrw

And would this trade be fair? (same deal, is it fair over or under? If it's under, what do I need to add?)
Trade 2) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YL882ofeZQ

It's an over pay. They basically just need the horse.

I don't know the first trade. The second one is way overpay, the horse is a store pet and worth a 09 rare. Your side does way not add up to that (:

[squonkasaurusrex]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HxnuxbpG5w

Is this fair? If not, what needs to be added?

[luc]

Is this fair? Thank you.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ah5LHvPIhA

Edit:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MhlzGErA4w
Is this fair? Bad at items ^^;

the skeleton mask and suit are a late '14 common, so the mask alone is probably only about a late '14 very common
couldn't find anything on the tattoo bunnies but they're from september '14; the ruby heart necklace was from valentine's '17

it looks a little unfair to them, i'd take away a very common from their side and all your items but the mask
i recommend getting another opinion though

Thank you, that's helpful. Can I get that second opinion? c:

[pigeon -]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63485281&userid=573067&signature=_9yfb9uciSNgZYCMCEjF7A

This fair? I'm REALLY tempted to accept it!

Honestly I would accept that. I gave someone an UR white malk for my lolita, and the light leopard isn't easy to trade away either. Honestly I've seen the lolita go for more.

Well, rarity wise unfair to you by a mid advent and a 09 rare. I'm not sure about lolita demand, it goes for overpay though, but a white malk dragon would be way overpay. And just because you paid that for a lolita, doesn't mean that's what it usually goes for (:

^^^ Thing Is i traded about 5-6 people the white malk and they all declined before I got an accepted trade for it.

personally i agree with joof, yes the lolita can go for overpay but demand
differs per person, for my four lolitas i've managed to get them for tier
swaps up to the winged blood dog tier ; so i guess it just depends on
who you're trading with as to what they'll trade their lolita for c:

[.crossfire.]

Would this trade be fair, over, or under? If it's under, what do I need to add?
Trade 1) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4fcD5rLCrw

And would this trade be fair? (same deal, is it fair over or under? If it's under, what do I need to add?)
Trade 2) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YL882ofeZQ

It's an over pay. They basically just need the horse.

Are both trades overpay?

Im not sure about number one. But I believe it is

[saucycorndog]

Just got this one, Opinions? Also Would both Balloon Dogs be fair for my UR Dog (The grey and blue one) All help is appreciated!!