The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Ironic Equation]

Fair considering demand?

[KaceyCat]

So, um, I kinda freaked out when I saw how many they were offering, until I saw what they were asking for. I know the puppy on my side will grow up to be a July 2009 rare or very rare.

I'm torn, because they are offering a few choice pets in the mix that I find aesthetically pleasing. But I also like what the pup will grow up to be.

So really, is this fair, and would you advise accepting it?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42185401&userid=122683&signature=SwhqQXE7wlS2-iNdk4KCJg

[Demonking Urizen]

Triclolor Tess Cake Dog + ? = Lime Ice Rat
Thank you <3

[Delta Dawn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42184772&userid=666640&signature=x_LBg7hK58j6jJAtfd8Gww
Is this fair?
Thank you

If I were you, I'd keep the horse till it grows up, that way you will know its true value but its up to you ^.^

[trickszy]

Is this still whats fair for this horse since I got another one today xD
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9M1-Z8lngA

Dude. That's definitely not fair. That horse is on the advent list. Even with the C$, it's not fair at all to you.

[lucifer morningstar]

So, um, I kinda freaked out when I saw how many they were offering, until I saw what they were asking for. I know the puppy on my side will grow up to be a July 2009 rare or very rare.

I'm torn, because they are offering a few choice pets in the mix that I find aesthetically pleasing. But I also like what the pup will grow up to be.

So really, is this fair, and would you advise accepting it?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42185401&userid=122683&signature=SwhqQXE7wlS2-iNdk4KCJg

Personally, I would hang onto it. It has the chance of becoming a main list pet.
If it turns out to be one of the rare outcomes, it looks unfair to them. If it turns out to be a very rare outcome, unfair to you. If it turned into the Wolf PPS, which is a main list, it would be really unfair to you.

Is this still whats fair for this horse since I got another one today xD
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9M1-Z8lngA

Dude. That's definitely not fair. That horse is on the advent list. Even with the C$, it's not fair at all to you.

Please don't post false advice. Yes, the horse is on the advent list, but 75 C$ would be worth a mid advent, which is a few tiers above the tess horse. The tess horse is only worth 60 C$.

[trickszy]

Fair considering demand?

Not fair--UR Phoenix is a few tiers above the non-coon.

[knightsofshame]

Fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z44Bfstl_A

[trickszy]

So, um, I kinda freaked out when I saw how many they were offering, until I saw what they were asking for. I know the puppy on my side will grow up to be a July 2009 rare or very rare.

I'm torn, because they are offering a few choice pets in the mix that I find aesthetically pleasing. But I also like what the pup will grow up to be.

So really, is this fair, and would you advise accepting it?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42185401&userid=122683&signature=SwhqQXE7wlS2-iNdk4KCJg

Definite trade-down. Not sure what your pup is, but that's an undertrade, according to date. If that dog is from July, then it's definitely not fair because of the three-month rule.

[lucky333123]

So, um, I kinda freaked out when I saw how many they were offering, until I saw what they were asking for. I know the puppy on my side will grow up to be a July 2009 rare or very rare.

I'm torn, because they are offering a few choice pets in the mix that I find aesthetically pleasing. But I also like what the pup will grow up to be.

So really, is this fair, and would you advise accepting it?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42185401&userid=122683&signature=SwhqQXE7wlS2-iNdk4KCJg

Definite trade-down. Not sure what your pup is, but that's an undertrade, according to date. If that dog is from July, then it's definitely not fair because of the three-month rule.

Most likely will be unfair to you. You could have a main list, so I would wait until your dog grows.